The official Gannon/Monti/Petzing should be fired thread……

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
16,269
Reaction score
17,033
See this is just a Stockholm syndrome excuse for GMs
this presumes a GM can sign any UFA they want. I dont think thats true as the player gets a vote there.

the error was letting Allen get to UFA. You just cant let players you want to keep get there as it is then out of your control
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
41,645
Reaction score
37,136
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Thats my point.

Why do we have guys that were terrible at spotting talent still here?
I don’t think there’s evidence for this. Every FO has hits and misses when it comes to college and pro scouting.

We should always look to exceed the average, but I think you that by finding and adding exceptional scouts, not putting the guys you already have in the circular file.
 

602 Native

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Nov 1, 2023
Posts
4,450
Reaction score
8,075
Location
Gilbert
I don’t think there’s evidence for this. Every FO has hits and misses when it comes to college and pro scouting.

We should always look to exceed the average, but I think you that by finding and adding exceptional scouts, not putting the guys you already have in the circular file.
Keims people / Rod Graves people have been here too long. There is definetly evidence that Keim's people were trash.
 

DJCard

Newbie
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Posts
1
Reaction score
1
Location
Alberta
I agree that Monti, JG, and DP have made major mistakes. So have the players (too many to mention). But why does no one mention that, by my limited research, over the first seven games our defense has only forced five punts in the fourth quarter, they have only had two sacks (both by CC against Carolina), and the only time there was a defensive takeaway in the fourth quarter - the Titans scored an effing touchdown.

This is after the defense was bolstered in both free agency and the draft this year. What would our record be if our defense was overachieving in the fourth quarter, or at least not underachieving? Has NR stepped up his game this year or regressed? Does he get a pass as it seemed like he did more with less talent last tear?

We are a young inexperienced team with young inexperienced coaches. But if we get rid of all the coaches and players who have let us down this year, there won’t be much of a foundation to build upon. While the season has been an epic disappointment thus far, hopefully getting some injured players back (and maybe saying goodbye to some others) will provide some pleasant surprises between now week 18. Otherwise we are likely back to major rebuild mode.
 

oaken1

Stone Cold
Supporting Member
Banned from P+R
Joined
Mar 13, 2004
Posts
22,251
Reaction score
22,157
Location
Modesto, California
I don’t think there’s evidence for this. Every FO has hits and misses when it comes to college and pro scouting.

We should always look to exceed the average, but I think you that by finding and adding exceptional scouts, not putting the guys you already have in the circular file.
Right?

There isn't a limit right??
A rule that says they can only have 8 scouts under contract?
They should be trying to get them all.
 

Ouchie-Z-Clown

I'm better than Mulli!
Joined
Sep 16, 2002
Posts
68,573
Reaction score
66,075
Location
SoCal
this presumes a GM can sign any UFA they want. I dont think thats true as the player gets a vote there.

the error was letting Allen get to UFA. You just cant let players you want to keep get there as it is then out of your control
It presumes nothing. They CAN sign any UFA they want. The rules literally allow it. Hence the “U” in “UFA.” It’s whether they’re capable of convincing them or not that’s part of the equation of what makes them a bad-mediocre-good-great GM. The presumption is that they canNOT sign them, that’s faulty reasoning.
 

Jersey Girl

Stand down
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2002
Posts
32,744
Reaction score
7,096
Location
Super Scottsdale
Blow it up. Start over. We didn't even play today and I'm pissed. Watching some of these other teams and seeing what we are doing makes me angry. How many times do we watch a play get ready to develop and just know it's gonna be bad?

And I agree with whoever posted wherever about having to "rebuild" every four years. I miss Arians.
 
Back
Top