There’s still a possibility we draft Nabers

[MadCardDisease]

Chris Simms (@simmsunbuttoned) on Threads

Here’s my Top 5 WRs. Rankings based on film. Awesome group. So much to like with Nabers, Thomas, and Harrison. I just think the LSU guys are able to separate more and run by you better than Harrison

www.threads.net

You must be registered for see images attach

I think all of those top four guys are going to be really good in the NFL.

Look at the insane stats that they put up in college:

2023 NCAA College Football Leaders & Stats - Receiving Stats | FOX Sports

View 2023 NCAA College Football leaders and Receiving stats.

www.foxsports.com

 

[Proximo]

I’m not even sure he’s “better” like @Krangodnzr and a few others I think many are just enamored with his namesake.

I think I agree.

I keep looking at his highlights and I feel like I must be missing something, he doesn't look like a physical freak or clearly the best WR prospect in years like so many seem convinced he is. I mean he looks good, but I really don't understand so many people on here acting like a trade down would be insanely stupid.

 

[Stout]

I think I agree.

I keep looking at his highlights and I feel like I must be missing something, he doesn't look like a physical freak or clearly the best WR prospect in years like so many seem convinced he is. I mean he looks good, but I really don't understand so many people on here acting like a trade down would be insanely stupid.

I would strongly prefer not to trade down at all, but that's just because I've settled on him being the best WR prospect and that's who I want us to get. I'd be upset but not pissed if we traded down one spot and nabbed Odunze, as we need size on the outside and he's the one who has it, not Nabers. Trading down far enough to take us out of the elite prospect level (with those 3 sure to be off the board) would be a total Cards thing to do. "We'll get a haul and, eh, hope one of these other WRs is a star--who needs a top pick talent?"

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

I would strongly prefer not to trade down at all, but that's just because I've settled on him being the best WR prospect and that's who I want us to get. I'd be upset but not pissed if we traded down one spot and nabbed Odunze, as we need size on the outside and he's the one who has it, not Nabers. Trading down far enough to take us out of the elite prospect level (with those 3 sure to be off the board) would be a total Cards thing to do. "We'll get a haul and, eh, hope one of these other WRs is a star--who needs a top pick talent?"

I live here

 

[Yuma]

Chris Simms (@simmsunbuttoned) on Threads

Here’s my Top 5 WRs. Rankings based on film. Awesome group. So much to like with Nabers, Thomas, and Harrison. I just think the LSU guys are able to separate more and run by you better than Harrison

www.threads.net

You must be registered for see images attach

That order seems nuts, but I like Brian Thomas Junior. 6'3" with a 4.3 forty time. Take the top off!

 

[602 Native]

Chris Simms (@simmsunbuttoned) on Threads

Here’s my Top 5 WRs. Rankings based on film. Awesome group. So much to like with Nabers, Thomas, and Harrison. I just think the LSU guys are able to separate more and run by you better than Harrison

www.threads.net

You must be registered for see images attach

Simms thought Zach Wilson was the best QB in his draft.
Ignore anything he says.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

Simms thought Zach Wilson was the best QB in his draft.
Ignore anything he says.

Oh c'mon. None of them are perfect and he's far from the only person to have that thought about Wilson.

 

[Cheesebeef]

man... if we pass on MJH for one of those other WRs, Monty better be damn sure he's pulling off the Edgerrin James surprise pick over Ricky Williams back in the day.

 

[602 Native]

Oh c'mon. None of them are perfect and he's far from the only person to have that thought about Wilson.

Zach Wilson was a nobody in college. To grade him over Tlawrence is awful.

Just like grading the #2 WR for LSU over MHJ.

 

[Krangodnzr]

I would strongly prefer not to trade down at all, but that's just because I've settled on him being the best WR prospect and that's who I want us to get. I'd be upset but not pissed if we traded down one spot and nabbed Odunze, as we need size on the outside and he's the one who has it, not Nabers. Trading down far enough to take us out of the elite prospect level (with those 3 sure to be off the board) would be a total Cards thing to do. "We'll get a haul and, eh, hope one of these other WRs is a star--who needs a top pick talent?"

I only want a trade down for a total haul. MHJ is a markedly better prospect than any player in the 2023 draft and I think Odunze might be as well.

 

[bankybruce]

Simms thought Zach Wilson was the best QB in his draft.
Ignore anything he says.

I don't have an opinion. I posted because it seems relevant. I have watched enough of these guys to have a top choice aside form what I know of MHJ.

 

[ASUCHRIS]

I only want a trade down for a total haul. MHJ is a markedly better prospect than any player in the 2023 draft and I think Odunze might be as well.

It better be historical - we can't keep messing around with pick hoarding with desperate needs.

 

[Krangodnzr]

It better be historical - we can't keep messing around with pick hoarding with desperate needs.

I'm doing it only for A LOT of picks. And that also means we get some this year and next. The kinds of drafts that a smart front office can turn into a foundation of a team, or use to trade for young stars.

 

[ASUCHRIS]

I'm doing it only for A LOT of picks. And that also means we get some this year and next. The kinds of drafts that a smart front office can turn into a foundation of a team, or use to trade for young stars.

Yeah, after the whole "we're going to get two top 10 picks, maybe top 5" after last year, I'm a little chastened, especially if we trade out of MHJ/Odzune territory. That won't likely net us a major haul - only a Vikings like pick where we're likely to miss out on the top 3 WR. At that point, no thx.

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

I'm doing it only for A LOT of picks. And that also means we get some this year and next. The kinds of drafts that a smart front office can turn into a foundation of a team, or use to trade for young stars.

There's a reason teams are willing to give up alot of picks or a "haul" for an elite prospect. Because that haul rarely turns into anything of significance. Give me the elite prospect every time.

 

[Shane]

There's a reason teams are willing to give up alot of picks or a "haul" for an elite prospect. Because that haul rarely turns into anything of significance. Give me the elite prospect every time.

Signed the Vikings in Oct 1989…..

 

[kerouac9]

Signed the Vikings in Oct 1989…..

Dude if you have to go back 35 years you’re doing it wrong

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

Signed the Vikings in Oct 1989…..

 

[Shane]

Dude if you have to go back 35 years you’re doing it wrong

Ok then:

https://www.si.com/nfl/2023/08/23/hauls-dolphins-eagles-cowboys-show-how-badly-49ers-whiffed-trey-lance-trade#:~:text=12%3F,worse%20from%20San%20Francisco's%20perspective.

 

[Shane]

I mean there is more examples too if you care to look

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

There's a reason teams are willing to give up alot of picks or a "haul" for an elite prospect. Because that haul rarely turns into anything of significance. Give me the elite prospect every time.

Exactly. Being stoked for a Herschel walker type deal is a thing is because of how rare one of those deals turns out as a homerun.

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

Signed the Vikings in Oct 1989…..

Does the fact you can only cite one from 35 years ago mean anything to you? Anything?

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

Ok then:

https://www.si.com/nfl/2023/08/23/hauls-dolphins-eagles-cowboys-show-how-badly-49ers-whiffed-trey-lance-trade#:~:text=12%3F,worse%20from%20San%20Francisco's%20perspective.

No one thought he was a blue chipper. That would be like somehow giving up a haul for jJ this year. No way he is worth it. Mega deal trades for rookie QBs tend to be kinda stupid.

 

[Shane]

No one thought he was a blue chipper. That would be like somehow giving up a haul for jJ this year. No way he is worth it. Mega deal trades for rookie QBs tend to be kinda stupid.

Actually the Niners obviously did CLEARLY and most on here tend to think their brain trust is pretty genius sooooo….

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

Actually the Niners obviously did CLEARLY and most on here tend to think their brain trust is pretty genius sooooo….

No they thought he was a QBOF. As I said, those deals are almost all stupid.