Man, Early, this post is outstanding!
As you know, I am very high on Kerrigan too.
The thing is...even though you have the guts to point out a real truth about what's expected of DEs in this 34...we won't get rid of Dockett. We have to hope that Dockett will be inspired by Horton to play the two gap as strong and as determined as he can and still be able to exploit gaps weh he is asked to twist and stunt.
What are your takes on Robert Quinn, Justin Houston and Aldon Smith?
It messes things up that you need to play one player on that D-Line in one gap style and two/three others playing two gap. It gets way to complex and it restrains the defense behind the first level, as far as second and third level, you get restrains due to Docket not being able to play two gap and contain the run two dimensionally. He is a freak controlling that one gap in one dimension. But if that doesn't suit the defense, why keep him???
I would trade him for a first rounder, if that can give me Cameron Jordan. He will become a decent passrusher, but man can he play the two gap, shed blocks, pursuit along the line, open up linebackers, he is so smart and dedicated, disciplined, and he doesn't take plays off. And he adds some value as passrusher.
I love Aldon Smith. But i love him inside , not outside. He is a complete mismatch against guards with that first step and extremely long arms for that frame, but also against tackles, but less so. He knows how to use his hands, that's for sure to get separation from the inside.
He reminds me of a more athletic but less powerfull Calais Campbell that also exhibits the same technique from the inside. I would love to see him bulk up and be used as Justin Tuck. He is more a fit if used like that for 4-3 teams than 3-4 teams. He can also make a good edge rusher in either scheme, more project here than Kerrigan, but i like him.
I need to watch more of Houston and Quinn. I have seen two games from Quinn, and i wasn't impressed at all like i was with Kerrigan. It's more flashes and athleticism, while with Kerrigan it's consistency and technique and pressure almost every snap in some form or another. Quinn is not a technician. Is much more athletic, but it's not like he has no technique at all either. Houston, i haven't seen a single game on him where i watch him every play.
I think we need to get either Jordan or Wilkerson, these guys are way too good to pass on.
I'm also in love with Jimmy Smith, CB. Truth is that he has Nnamdi Asomugha stats in college, he has dominated and i do see that watching his games. I don't remember the exact number right now, but it was redicilous, it was a number you can compare to Nnamdi's in NFL, redicilous low number of completed passes against him and even more so targeted passes. Teams just stay away from his side, QB's don't even look there.
If you watch close, he can really get the hands on you on LOSm they are long and he is good at it, and he has fluid hips and he is so good to come under a route. Every team looking for man coverage abilities should consider this guy. I know we are not going to play man, so we may not be the best fit, but his skills are amazing for another scheme, Jets, Raiders, Baltimore etc. His tackling isn't the best, so that's not so good.
Clayborn and Ballard - full of potential. Usually i'm VERY critical of lineman coming into the draft. Last year i was only in love with Alualu and Suh and Smith (Jaguars as well, IR from game one) for their technical abilities and their potential to produce early on in the career. This year, it's just loaded with talent. Clayborn also shows these flashes of shedding pursuiting dominating LOS, even putting pressure on the QB. At times he is unblockable. Than he disseapears, so he is not consistent as Jordan at all. Ballard, the same. Very nice flashes and then gets away and is not there and than dominates again. Both these guys can turn up really good, they have some technique already now at this point.
But there is only three guys i see as can't miss even from early on:
Jordan, Wilkerson, Kerrigan. NFl technique on college level.
Then, there is bunch of guys this year that already in college have shown to posses some technique that you usually acquire and learn on next level. It's a long list and some of them are even big athletes.