The official Gannon/Monti/Petzing should be fired thread……

Would you fire Gannon if they don’t make the playoffs?

  • I’m in favor of keeping him regardless of what happens the remainder of the season

    Votes: 56 41.2%
  • I’m in favor of keeping him if they improve on last years record (9 wins or more)

    Votes: 15 11.0%
  • I’m in favor of keeping him if they just make the playoffs

    Votes: 15 11.0%
  • I’m only in favor of keeping him if they win a playoff game

    Votes: 11 8.1%
  • Fire Gannon no matter what

    Votes: 44 32.4%

  • Total voters
    136

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
33,374
Reaction score
56,246
Location
Colorado
A lot of excuses happening for Monti & Gannon on this page.
Devil's advocate perspective...how many GM/HC combos would be competitive in their first stints while being handcuffed by a meh QB and terrible owner? While I didn't love either when we hired them and did not like their initial plan, I completely understand the willingness to give the two more time due to the surrounding circumstances and malaise this franchise is. It doesn't mean they will work out, but let's not undersell the mess this franchise historically is.
 

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
17,037
Reaction score
19,061
Devil's advocate perspective...how many GM/HC combos would be competitive in their first stints while being handcuffed by a meh QB and terrible owner? While I didn't love either when we hired them and did not like their initial plan, I completely understand the willingness to give the two more time due to the surrounding circumstances and malaise this franchise is. It doesn't mean they will work out, but let's not undersell the mess this franchise historically is.
I am very torn.

I have posted on Montis strategic failures, especially this offseason. I have posted on the coaching staff's bad decisions during games (a couple, just inexcusable decisions).

what am I torn over?

At some point, this franchise cant just keep firing and starting over every 3 years. If Gannon goes, the team will have had 4 HCs in 8 seasons after Arians.

Every time a new coach is hired -- the roster turns over to get guys for the new scheme. Inevitably, good players are lost (like Zach Allen) as a result.


So -- IF there is a change, something bigger has to change at the same time. My 100% guaranteed to work (or your money back) plan:

Hire Greg Olsen of TV fame to come in a be President of Football. Let him decide on Monti / Gannon / etc.

It might be Matt Millen with the Lions, it might be John Lynch with the 49ers.
 

DVontel

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jan 28, 2015
Posts
15,543
Reaction score
29,860
Devil's advocate perspective...how many GM/HC combos would be competitive in their first stints while being handcuffed by a meh QB and terrible owner? While I didn't love either when we hired them and did not like their initial plan, I completely understand the willingness to give the two more time due to the surrounding circumstances and malaise this franchise is. It doesn't mean they will work out, but let's not undersell the mess this franchise historically is.
Gannon could have done what Ben Johnson did & pass on a franchise that is historical awful with an awful owner. Same goes for Monti.
 

phillycard

ASFN Addict
Joined
Aug 22, 2003
Posts
8,215
Reaction score
6,240
Location
The 215
Well as long as you don’t change your opinion in the face of contradictory evidence, I guess. So #2025
Evidence? It's all perception good brother. :thumbup: Plenty of head coaches have taken jobs where they didn't necessarily believe in the QB. Reports are that Ben Johnson isn't all rainbows and gummy bears over Caleb, but he's going to have to make it work for the immediate future.

You think Gannon's a standup guy. I think he's a corny clown.

And him going to an event in K1's honor proves absolutely nothing.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
44,065
Reaction score
42,383
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Evidence? It's all perception good brother. :thumbup: Plenty of head coaches have taken jobs where they didn't necessarily believe in the QB. Reports are that Ben Johnson isn't all rainbows and gummy bears over Caleb, but he's going to have to make it work for the immediate future.

You think Gannon's a standup guy. I think he's a corny clown.

And him going to an event in K1's honor proves absolutely nothing.
It doesn’t PROVE anything, but it certainly contradicts some cockamamie theory that Gannon and Monti never liked Kyler and were just waiting for him to… be mid? Fail and potentially take their careers down with him?

Gannon running down tha hall to meet Kyler wasn’t necessary to confirm that Kyler was his dude; same with going to Norman OK. Why on the extra mile if you don’t mean it?

We saw what the other side of the coin looks like with Russ in Denver. This wasn’t that.
 

phillycard

ASFN Addict
Joined
Aug 22, 2003
Posts
8,215
Reaction score
6,240
Location
The 215
It doesn’t PROVE anything, but it certainly contradicts some cockamamie theory that Gannon and Monti never liked Kyler and were just waiting for him to… be mid? Fail and potentially take their careers down with him?

Gannon running down tha hall to meet Kyler wasn’t necessary to confirm that Kyler was his dude; same with going to Norman OK. Why on the extra mile if you don’t mean it?

We saw what the other side of the coin looks like with Russ in Denver. This wasn’t that.
Don't put words in my mouth. I never said he wanted him to fail or even be mid or as you put it, and I said ZERO about Monti. I said he was never Gannon's guy. I believed it then and I believe it now. Obviously, they felt they could maximize his abilities since he was already enmeshed as the man. JG would be a fool not to recognize his talents, but that doesn't mean he WANTED him. And getting on a plane to support the franchise qb isn't going the extra mile IMO. It's what an org should do. It would have been a pretty bad look had no one from the Cards been there to support him. If Gannon and Kyler are going to die on the same hill then so be it. We will all be the worse for it in the end. Oh, and Payton's a clown as well, so I'm not at all concerned with what happened with him and Russ.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
44,065
Reaction score
42,383
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Thats my point.

Why do we have guys that were terrible at spotting talent still here?
I don’t think there’s evidence for this. Every FO has hits and misses when it comes to college and pro scouting.

We should always look to exceed the average, but I think you that by finding and adding exceptional scouts, not putting the guys you already have in the circular file.
 

Krangodnzr

Captain of Team Conner
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Posts
37,433
Reaction score
36,882
Location
Charlotte, NC
Gannon could have done what Ben Johnson did & pass on a franchise that is historical awful with an awful owner. Same goes for Monti.
Eh the Bears are basically historically awful now too. They really haven't been a really good team for a long time.
 

phillycard

ASFN Addict
Joined
Aug 22, 2003
Posts
8,215
Reaction score
6,240
Location
The 215
@phillycard how are we supposed to parse this?
K, come on man. Now you're getting into semantics. If you're trying to catch me in some "gotcha" moment. It's not gonna happen. Seeing him gone fits the same narrative I said initially. He's not Gannon's man. You can slice it however you want. That's your boy you're gonna cape for him regardless. It is what it is.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
33,374
Reaction score
56,246
Location
Colorado
Gannon & Monti should have known what they were getting into working for an owner like Bidwill. They could have avoided the “meh QB”. They chose not to. Lets stop the scapegoating others.
The counter is that just because they knew what they were getting into doesn't make it any easier to overcome.
 

Harry

ASFN Consultant and Senior Writer
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Posts
16,603
Reaction score
38,571
Location
Orlando, FL
I don’t think anyone was rooting for Murray to fail. He just wasn’t what they saw as optimal in a QB. I think at first there was hope if they could build a dominant defense and play conservatively on offense they had a chance to be a playoff team. I think they saw riding out Murray’s contact as an option, not a mandate I think, like most coaches, they could improve Murray’s performance. They have somewhat but not enough to carry the offense. I think they’ve been caught off guard that the defense was good but not great. Injuries destroyed the run first concept and they overestimated the Oline.
 

602 Native

ASFN Addict
Joined
Nov 1, 2023
Posts
5,989
Reaction score
11,039
Location
Gilbert
I don’t think there’s evidence for this. Every FO has hits and misses when it comes to college and pro scouting.

We should always look to exceed the average, but I think you that by finding and adding exceptional scouts, not putting the guys you already have in the circular file.
Keims people / Rod Graves people have been here too long. There is definetly evidence that Keim's people were trash.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
33,374
Reaction score
56,246
Location
Colorado
It's so tough because everyone on this board pretty much knows the issue is Bidwill, but when Monti and Gannon struggle (I omitted Kyler because there is another thread for that) people minimize that Bidwill is the issue. I have zero clue if Monti and Gannon are able to ever be good, but I also can't really expect anyone to come in and turn things around in three years. I know Arians did it, but Bidwill still managed to mess that up.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,333,059
Posts
6,547,494
Members
6,431
Latest member
Arlene Lake
Top