I think that Kyler Murray's career is finished with his injury

[DVontel]

I could see him look at baseball now. It would allow him to drop some muscle and take some pressure off his knees.

I'm now sure how that impacts the cap, though, if he retired for baseball.

This baseball talk has to decease. He’s just not going to drop in like he’s Mike Trout & have a long successful career. That ship has sailed the second he chose the NFL over MLB.

 

[dreamcastrocks]

Kyler isnt a problem.

However, imo it just sucks that he isnt much of a solution. I truly thought he could play well/win in spite of everything else.

Kyler's play is a problem.

 

[PDXChris]

This baseball talk has to decease. He’s just not going to drop in like he’s Mike Trout & have a long successful career. That ship has sailed the second he chose the NFL over MLB.

He's 25 and has $100 million in the back. It's still an option, but the window is very small.

 

[SoonerLou]

Kyler's play is a problem.

Eh. His QBR was closer to 60 when playing with Hopkins.

To me Kyler was a problem those 1st 6 games. He's totally dependent on really good WRs.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

He's 25 and has $100 million in the back. It's still an option, but the window is very small.

He hasn't played in 4+ years and will be coming off a major injury. Not happening. If he retires from football, he will become a professional gamer....bank it. This isn't a slight on him as QB at all...I don't care that he plays video games. I'm 50+ and still play games. haha I just think if he's good at it, I could see that as a plausible future for sure, if/when football is done.

 

[jf-08]

This is how it is

Good = very little criticism
Poor = more criticism
Bad = lots of criticism

Hold on, let me get a crayon and write this down....

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[82CardsGrad]

Or he recovers well and adjusts his game to rely less on his athletic ability

That would be the ideal scenario... But if Kliffy is still here, I can guarantee we won't ever see this ideal scenario play out.

 

[PDXChris]

He hasn't played in 4+ years and will be coming off a major injury. Not happening. If he retires from football, he will become a professional gamer....bank it. This isn't a slight on him as QB at all...I don't care that he plays video games. I'm 50+ and still play games. haha I just think if he's good at it, I could see that as a plausible future for sure, if/when football is done.

While that is definitely a possibility, I still think he considers it. He's a million times more gifted than Tebow athletically, and Tebow was 29 when he tried.

And for the record, I said he'd look at baseball but didnt say he actually make the jump.

 

[LoyalRam]

Snap.

He isn't done as a runner and it won't change his game. Running backs do ACL's every year and still play running back.

Actual runners do ACL's and come back and compete at a high level.

He'll be fine physically. The question is how it effects him mentally.

Maybe Kyler will come out just fine from this MCL knee injury, but he may not. Our RB Cam Akers blew out his knee a couple years ago and McVay has been trying to get the pre-injury production from Cam all year and he has sucked. He's not the same guy....

 

[Fiasco]

Uh oh,

Experts predict delayed recovery for Kyler Murray because he can't read a set of crutches

 

[Card'em]

Maybe Kyler will come out just fine from this MCL knee injury, but he may not. Our RB Cam Akers blew out his knee a couple years ago and McVay has been trying to get the pre-injury production from Cam all year and he has sucked. He's not the same guy....

If you want to look at examples of players that have had ACL injuries on the Rams I think you start with Cooper Kupp. He still performed at a high level the year following his ACL and obviously has continued to do so. You just never know how a player will respond after ACL surgery. It depends on the specific injury and the player. Nobody knows how this will effect him, but obviously there is cause for concern.

 

[TheCardFan]

Here are several examples on QB's tearing ACL:

Deshaun Watson's ACL recovery: How other QBs have fared after surgery

Tom Brady and Carson Palmer returned after ACL tears and were just as strong, but others in the same situation as Deshaun Watson haven't been as lucky.

www.espn.com

Surgeon details Bengals QB Joe Burrow's recovery from knee procedure

Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow suffered a gruesome knee injury that cut short his rookie season. NFL Network Insider Ian Rapoport spoke to the doctor who operated on Burrow's knee to get the details on his recovery ahead of Super Bowl LVI.

www.nfl.com

 

[mobyhammy]

I disagree that this is the end of Kyler's career. Even without the injury, Kyler was going to have to figure out how to be more of a pocket passer as he got older. What will determine success or failure is whether Kyler can develop into a quarterback who can read defenses and go through his reads.

Unlike others on this forum, I've loved the way Kyler played. It was fast and furious and unlike anything we've ever seen. But it was also unsustainable. Last year, he was unstoppable until defenses caught up to him. Still, Kyler's got unbelievable talent, not just his legs, but his arm as well. Maybe the injury will force him to adapt and become the quarterback we need him to be.

 

[slanidrac16]

In conclusion, Kyler return better than ever…..let’s hope he’s better.

 

[Finito]

They have pretty much sucked since 1948 so Kyler playing or not isn’t really a factor

Lol how many winning seasons since the team has been in Arizona?

The sooner cardinals fans realize this origination is pure trash the sooner they can move on with life.

Last year was my last year of giving a F and honestly I feel great.

 

[Finito]

Troy hates the Cards, always has.

But he’s not wrong

 

[football karma]

Maybe Kyler will come out just fine from this MCL knee injury, but he may not. Our RB Cam Akers blew out his knee a couple years ago and McVay has been trying to get the pre-injury production from Cam all year and he has sucked. He's not the same guy....

that was an achilles rather than an ACL

 

[PACardsFan]

Eh. His QBR was closer to 60 when playing with Hopkins.

To me Kyler was a problem those 1st 6 games. He's totally dependent on really good WRs.

Most QB’s are. How good is Rodgers without Adams? Of Herbert without Williams and/or Allen?

 

[redheat]

Kyler is not adjusting his game. He’s too athletic and used to not being touched at all. He can’t operate from the pocket. He’s the easiest tackle in the game if you just get near him. He plays scared and it contributed to his injury last night.
He’ll come back but his mindset won’t change nor his height. He will run out this contract or get cut in a few years. He will not sign another in the NFL.

 

[football karma]

Kyler will be back

the things he has going for him:

he is young

also, that non-contact injury is typically a rupture and isolated to the single ligament --- in contrast to an injury like Zach Ertz or Maxx Williams where it was caused by an outside force which can sometimes damage the MCL and /or cartilage

 

[LoyalRam]

If you want to look at examples of players that have had ACL injuries on the Rams I think you start with Cooper Kupp. He still performed at a high level the year following his ACL and obviously has continued to do so. You just never know how a player will respond after ACL surgery. It depends on the specific injury and the player. Nobody knows how this will effect him, but obviously there is cause for concern.

Cooper Kupp is a freak, in a good way. Kupp has always been a work out maniac and perfectionist. Cam came back from his MCL surgery during the Super Bowl year and so that was incredibly fast as well, but he hasn't been the same. Adrian Peterson was a freak too when he came back so fast and so you just never know until they get back on the field...

 

[DaHilg]

Most QB’s are. How good is Rodgers without Adams? Of Herbert without Williams and/or Allen?

Or how good was Allen w out Diggs? Tua w out Hill? Hurts w out Brown?

Answer; they all stunk! And that’s with better Olines and better coaching

 

[SissyBoyFloyd]

We probably will not know how Kyler will be following the surgery by draft time. This probably means that we will be forced to ´ waste ´ our high pick on a qb. You can´t come out of the draft not knowing if you have a qb or not. And it looks now like we will have a top 3 pick or so. That Levis kid sounds like he could be a starter after a few years of proper tutoring. But are the Cards the team to give him proper tutoring? Maybe if we hire a special QB guru just for him.

That might not be a bad thing in the long run. If Kyler can come back and start, that will give the rookie a few years to prepare to start. If Kyler is never the same again, we have Josh Allen type rookie to learn on the job. I just can not see us thinking Colt is a safe fall back position long term.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

The baseball theories are really dumb. As if one can just snap their fingers and play baseball at a professional level after 5 years away from the game.

 

[Cheesebeef]

The baseball theories are really dumb. As if one can just snap their fingers and play baseball at a professional level after 5 years away from the game.

Agreed