Why can’t we win?

MaoTosiFanClub

The problem
Joined
Oct 7, 2003
Posts
13,034
Reaction score
7,686
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
The bones of the organization aren’t any worse than the other family-owned (not acquired by a billionaire) teams in the NFL. And from a market perspective we are fine as there’s plenty of money in Arizona. So there must be other reasons and here’s my thoughts:

1. Building the stadium in Glendale was a colossal failure and the other investments Bidwill family made in the area went belly up. The stadium itself was never supposed to be the big money maker for the Bidwill family, it was the development of the surrounding area which the family had tremendous money invested in. Most if not all of that disappeared with the GFC so Bidwill’s never truly obtained big wealth outside the team. I’d also suspect being in the west valley has reduced gate revenue 15-20% vs a downtown or East Valley site which over a couple decades is a lot of dough. That being said the Yorks made this same mistake and the Niners are fine.

2. Bill Sr. turned the team over to the wrong kid. Michael got the team because he was deemed the “smartest” because of his legal career. But lawyers often aren’t great business people. Lawyers are in constant CYA and ‘paralysis by analysis’ mode and make safe hires often based on resume and degree not pure talent. Lawyers are deliberate in firing and over-analytical in every aspect. Meanwhile the best businesspeople and owners delegate like crazy and take big swings.

3. The above permeates the overall culture of the franchise. It’s a very undynamic place to work and doesn’t really attract high-level talent outside of people who just want to live in Phoenix or will take any NFL job.

4. Michael Bidwill tying into the above again doesn’t have a great feel for being an NFL owner. He’s socially awkward and doesn’t have really any real friends nor wife or children so will never truly understand what leaving a real legacy means. His drive in running the Cardinals is more trying to fix the past not realizing that doing that kinda makes one ignore the future. He is significantly more obsessed with people not conflating the name Bidwill with incompetence or stupidity than he is making the Cardinals a benchmark of Arizona civic pride. He sees his role absolutely backwards: making the Cardinals something this city can be proud of is the only thing that’ll clear the family name.

Ultimately we simply have a bad owner that most people don’t want to work for and the ones who do he has a bad feel on who is good and who’s not.

So here we are, hoping enough egg builds up on the family’s face that they decide to cash their lottery ticket and a talented billionaire takes over.
 
Last edited:

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
42,784
Reaction score
39,688
Location
Gilbert, AZ
The bones of the organization aren’t any worse than the other family-owned (not acquired by a billionaire) teams in the NFL. And from a market perspective we are fine as there’s plenty of money in Arizona. So there must be other reasons and here’s my thoughts:

1. Building the stadium in Glendale was a colossal failure and the other investments Bidwill family made in the area went belly up. The stadium itself was never supposed to be the big money maker for the Bidwill family, it was the development of the surrounding area which the family had tremendous money invested in. Most if not all of that disappeared with the GFC so Bidwill’s never truly obtained big wealth outside the team. I’d also suspect being in the west valley has reduced gate revenue 15-20% vs a downtown or East Valley site which over a couple decades is a lot of dough. That being said the Yorks made this same mistake and the Niners are fine.

2. Bill Sr. turned the team over to the wrong kid. Michael got the team because he was deemed the “smartest” because of his legal career. But lawyers often aren’t great business people. Lawyers are in constant CYA and ‘paralysis by analysis’ mode and make safe hires often based on resume and degree not pure talent. Lawyers are deliberate in firing and over-analytical in every aspect. Meanwhile the best businesspeople and owners delegate like crazy and take big swings.

3. The above permeates the overall culture of the franchise. It’s a very undynamic place to work and doesn’t really attract high-level talent outside of people who just want to live in Phoenix or will take any NFL job.

4. Michael Bidwill tying into the above again doesn’t have a great feel for being an NFL owner. He’s socially awkward and doesn’t have really any real friends nor wife or children so will never truly understand what leaving a real legacy means. His drive in running the Cardinals is more trying to fix the past not realizing that doing that kinda makes one ignore the future. He is significantly more obsessed with people not conflating the name Bidwill with incompetence or stupidity than he is making the Cardinals a benchmark of Arizona civic pride. He sees his role absolutely backwards: making the Cardinals something this city can be proud of is the only thing that’ll clear the family name.

Ultimately we simply have a bad owner that most people don’t want to work for and the ones who do he has a bad feel on who is good and who’s not.

So here we are, hoping enough egg builds up on the family’s face that they decide to cash their lottery ticket and a talented billionaire takes over.


Well here’s what I have to say to this:

You must be registered for see images attach
 

MaoTosiFanClub

The problem
Joined
Oct 7, 2003
Posts
13,034
Reaction score
7,686
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
When you say bones do you mean garbage locker room? Casitas? No QB, RB, impact defensive players, GM?
Practice facility, stadium, etc.

In a way we have an inherent advantage in that most players and coaches would rather live here than probably 75% of other NFL markets including half our division.
 

Mulli

...
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2004
Posts
54,960
Reaction score
7,948
Location
Cold Harbor
More current and former players live here than anywhere except Miami, Dallas, Houston, LA.
Do you mean current players who can’t get enough Amazon shifts?

Ok that is mean.

Free agency paints a different picture right?
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
1,111,528
Posts
6,261,733
Members
6,416
Latest member
Testguy
Top