GM Poll - Monti or Keim?

[Cbus cardsfan]

This is like asking who is a better coach, Arians or Gannon?

 

[kerouac9]

The last three seasons of Keim — when he got fired — he went 23-27.

Again, Monti is 15-36.

The last four seasons Keim was 28-37-1.

Monti’s 2026 Cardinals would have to go 13-4 to match.

NEED MORE DATA TO DECIDE

 

[AsUpRoDiGy]

Monti will have more top 10 picks than winning seasons. He's terrible.

 

[Chopper0080]

Neither are good. Keim was a crap person by the end of his tenure but unquestionably is a better GM than Monti who is awful. Worst GM in the NFL. Probably worst GM in franchise history.

 

[ajcardfan]

Monti will have more top 10 picks than winning seasons. He's terrible.

I have a hard time understanding why Monti is winning this poll. It's so clearcut to me that Monti has been a train wreck. Maybe because Keim became so unlikable due to his personal flaws?

 

[602 Native]

Neither are good. Keim was a crap person by the end of his tenure but unquestionably is a better GM than Monti who is awful. Worst GM in the NFL. Probably worst GM in franchise history.

Said the same thing months ago.

MO is on another level of awful. This off season has been a masterclass in ineptitude at the most important position in sports.

 

[mel typer]

I'll go with the DUI count. It wasn't the DUI actually that got me but the lying and name dropping on the police body cam footage. I realize it's a business where you have to be that kind of a person but my God what a doucher

 

[602 Native]

The last three seasons of Keim — when he got fired — he went 23-27.

Again, Monti is 15-36.

The last four seasons Keim was 28-37-1.

Monti’s 2026 Cardinals would have to go 13-4 to match.

NEED MORE DATA TO DECIDE

Incredible that MO still has a job.

 

[kerouac9]

Cards 2025 defenses allowed the most points in franchise history.

The OBVIOUS solution to this was to let four of their top 12 players by snap count leave and replace them with… ??????

Also use your top three draft picks on offensive players

Good work, well done. Let’s get that extension ironed out.

 

[kerouac9]

Incredible that MO still has a job.

To me it’s even more incredible that fans here, who have eyes and have been following the team the past three-plus years, remain loyal to Monti, support pretty much every choice he makes, and think he just needs more time to get results.

 

[Goodyear Card]

Last year Monti drafted the WR of decade. This year he drafted the RB of the decade. Next year he will draft the QB of the decade. The 2030s will be the decade of the Cardinals with multiple Super Bowl wins. The future is bright.

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

Monti has done 1 good move. He signed Josh Sweat,who may want to be traded.

Tell me 1 other good thing that's worked out for him.
How can people support him? He's learning???? GMAFB. NFL GMs don't learn. They're ready.

I'm as big a Marv fan as anyone but he hasn't remotely performed to a high level. Maybe that's because of Monti's coaching hires.

 

[SECTION 11]

Should have Graves in the poll also.

 

[some dumb guy]

Monti has done 1 good move. He signed Josh Sweat,who may want to be traded.

Tell me 1 other good thing that's worked out for him.
How can people support him? He's learning???? GMAFB. NFL GMs don't learn. They're ready.

I'm as big a Marv fan as anyone but he hasn't remotely performed to a high level. Maybe that's because of Monti's coaching hires.

I have a very good feeling about MHJ this year. He's healthy again and will have a QB that will be able to actually see the field with his eyes. Don't know who that QB is yet or how good he'll be but I think Marv will look more like the player we hoped he'd be.

 

[mel typer]

I have a very good feeling about MHJ this year. He's healthy again and will have a QB that will be able to actually see the field with his eyes. Don't know who that QB is yet or how good he'll be but I think Marv will look more like the player we hoped he'd be.

I was all in for Harrison Jr. Was all in for Love too. I agree with this post and a lot forget it's a new offense in town along with Mr shorty gone

 

[Weenus O'Baggins]

I have a hard time understanding why Monti is winning this poll. It's so clearcut to me that Monti has been a train wreck. Maybe because Keim became so unlikable due to his personal flaws?

Kyler contract has blinded people with rage.

 

[iLLmatiC]

Monti couldn’t sniff Keims jock.

 

[iLLmatiC]

Keim's fingerprints are nearly completely gone from this team - in a very short amount of time. This article is from just last year.

Arizona Cardinals roster issues can be traced back to Steve Keim, Kliff Kingsbury drafts

The Cardinals have just six players remaining from their 2019-2022 drafts.

sports.yahoo.com

Update to this year, only 4 Keim draft picks are still on our roster (and at least one is not for long):

Kyler Murray, Trey McBride, Zaven Collins, and Jalen Thompson.

So our best player lol

 

[iLLmatiC]

Paris Johnson
Garrett Williams
Mike Wilson
Dante Stills
Tip Reiman
DTD
Walter Nolan
Will Johnson
Jordan Burch
Cody Simon
Denzel Burke

All of them have been very strong draft picks.

Williams
Stills
Nolan
Johnson
DTD
Burke

All have been exceptional for their draft position.

Sweat
Tomlinson
Campbell
Brissett

All great moves in FA

Locking up McBride is something the Cardinals could have/would have effed up many times with other GM’s.

Not a single pro bowler drafted lol

 

[Crimson Warrior]

Monti supporters better savor the next eight or nine games.

Because there is no universe where this defensive roster keeps him employed beyond that.

 

[SoonerLou]

Keim was much worse.

He essentially put Monti or whoever took this job behind a couple years. Obviously Kyler being injured (not his QB) and Gannon being inept (Monti deserves blame for this) doesnt help.

Still the organization suffers from the moves Keim did and didnt make till this day.

Good luck Monti.

 

[daves]

Cards 2025 defenses allowed the most points in franchise history.

The OBVIOUS solution to this was to let four of their top 12 players by snap count leave and replace them with… ??????

Also use your top three draft picks on offensive players

Good work, well done. Let’s get that extension ironed out.

Don't forget keeping the DC!

 

[LoyaltyisaCurse]

If only he had his way

AP and Mahomes

The question is why didn’t he?

 

[LoyaltyisaCurse]

A similar poll could be: What’s is better?

*Chronic explosive diarrhea

*Diverticulitis

 

[BullheadCardFan]

Don't forget keeping the DC!

Which is a mystery to all of us

Are we to believe that somehow Rallis will be different this time around?

I think he was forced on ML because MB didn't want to pay 2 DCs