Quarterback A vs. Quarterback B

[MaoTosiFanClub]

Quarterback A

Experience: 4 years
Draft: 3rd Round
Record as a Starter: 10-12
QB Rating: 72.1
Completion %: 57.7
Total Attempts: 862
Total Yards: 5431


Quarterback B

Experience: 4 years
Draft Round: 1st Round
Record as a Starter: 7-10
QB Rating: 70.8
Completion %: 57.1
Total Attempts: 595
Total Yard: 3893


Any guesses?

 

[82CardsGrad]

LMAO!! Great post dude!!

 

[TJ]

You mean QB A, who lost his job to Brady Quinn, had a 44% completion and had a game against the Bills where he threw 2 for 17

Anderson had one good season, which skews your statistical analysis. He has regressed drastically

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

You mean QB A, who lost his job to Brady Quinn, had a 44% completion and had a game against the Bills where he threw 2 for 17

Anderson had one good season, which skews your statistical analysis

Wrong, quarterback A isn't Anderson. This thread is meant more to illustrate how ridiculous the "sky is falling" crowd is in freaking out over dumping Leinart.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

Nope.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

Hint - both quarterbacks have been in competition with Kurt Warner at certain points in their careers.

 

[82CardsGrad]

Hint - both quarterbacks have been in competition with Kurt Warner at certain points in their careers.

Eli??

 

[TJ]

Wrong, quarterback A isn't Anderson. This thread is meant more to illustrate how ridiculous the "sky is falling" crowd is in freaking out over dumping Leinart.

Its not about Leinart being dumped, its about what we have left. Anderson is not the answer and is more than likely going to singlehandedly lose more games than he'll win. Maybe Leinart isnt the answer, but he is an accurate QB and would at least manage the game.

Our running game and defense are going to have to play 110% game in a game out to compensate for a lack of talent at the position.

 

[Mulli]

Whiz hates Leenert because he can't dunk a basketball.:coach:

 

[TJ]

McCown

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

You must be registered for see images

That's right. Our old boy Josh when the Cardinals dumped him to Oakland. Point is I don't recall anyone wringing their hands when we dumped that clown. Anderson might not have it, but then again neither does Leinart and ML is scheduled to make a ton of money.

This isn't the end of the world.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

Its not about Leinart being dumped, its about what we have left. Anderson is not the answer and is more than likely going to singlehandedly lose more games than he'll win. Maybe Leinart isnt the answer, but he is an accurate QB and would at least manage the game.

Saying Leinart is accurate and can manage a game is completely speculative as he's never really done that professionally. Look, Anderson is in all likelihood going to suck but that doesn't mean we should keep around a QB who's just as bad at 3x the money and attitude problems.

Our running game and defense are going to have to play 110% game in a game out to compensate for a lack of talent at the position.

Haha, like our defense and running game would've been able to slack off with Leinart and his 3 yard dump off's spearheading the offense? Give me a break.

 

[ASUCHRIS]

Wow, I'll take QB A!!!

The love affair around here for Leinart is borderline creepy.

 

[Shane]

I mentioned him in comparison to McCown once a long time ago. Got ripped for it. Whats funny is at the same pioint in their careers McCown was a better QB.

 

[TJ]

Saying Leinart is accurate and can manage a game is completely speculative as he's never really done that professionally. Look, Anderson is in all likelihood going to suck but that doesn't mean we should keep around a QB who's just as bad at 3x the money and attitude problems.

66% completion last season and 70% in the playoffs last year. He is accurate.

Haha, like our defense and running game would've been able to slack off with Leinart and his 3 yard dump off's spearheading the offense? Give me a break.

7+ YPA this preseason. That'd be enough to get it done as many of the good QBs in the game average that much. Doesnt matter how they get done, they just will. You hate Leinart. We've concluded that. But your argument against him just isnt convincing

 

[Mulli]

66% completion last season and 70% in the playoffs last year. He is accurate.



7+ YPA this preseason. That'd be enough to get it done as many of the good QBs in the game average that much. Doesnt matter how they get done, they just will. You hate Leinart. We've concluded that. But your argument against him just isnt convincing

Neither is your argument for him. Just ask the Whiz.

 

[WarnerHOF]

66% completion last season and 70% in the playoffs last year. He is accurate.



7+ YPA this preseason. That'd be enough to get it done as many of the good QBs in the game average that much. Doesnt matter how they get done, they just will. You hate Leinart. We've concluded that. But your argument against him just isnt convincing

David Carr once upon a time had a 68% completion for an entire season. Completion % is very a poor way to judge a QB's compared to the eyetest. Leianrt can throw short and accurate 5 yard passes to decent sized windows but the majority of his intermediate and deep passes are generally inaccurate.

 

[TJ]

Neither is your argument for him. Just ask the Whiz.

My argument, in short, is he is better than DA and at least gives us a shot at being a winner this season. With DA at the helm, we are effectively saying we are grooming either Hall or Skelton to take over in 2011.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

66% completion last season and 70% in the playoffs last year. He is accurate.

70% postseason completion rate, that's hilarious.

7+ YPA this preseason. That'd be enough to get it done as many of the good QBs in the game average that much. Doesnt matter how they get done, they just will. You hate Leinart. We've concluded that. But your argument against him just isnt convincing

He was comparable in almost every statistical category over the course of his first four years of his career to Josh freaking McCown. I'd say my argument holds a little bit of water.

 

[TJ]

70% postseason completion rate, that's hilarious.

7/10 in the New Orleans game. Hows that hilarious if its true?

He was comparable in almost every statistical category over the course of his first four years of his career to Josh freaking McCown. I'd say my argument holds a little bit of water.

The basis of your argument is the # of chances each QB had. Leinart had hardly any shot when Warner took over. This season would have been his first year without an HoF QB on the roster. Im convinced things would have been a lot easier.

 

[ASUCHRIS]

You hate Leinart. We've concluded that. But your argument against him just isnt convincing

Ha, who is we? You and K9 haven't come up with one convincing reason why Leinart is a significantly better option than Anderson, and you're argument degrades to people "hating" Leinart, the most puerile and idiotic position you can take.

You have to admit, comparing McCown and Leinart is pretty hilarious. The respective responses and contrast to losing both just illustrates how over the top ridiculous the board has gone over it.

 

[82CardsGrad]

My argument, in short, is he is better than DA and at least gives us a shot at being a winner this season. With DA at the helm, we are effectively saying we are grooming either Hall or Skelton to take over in 2011.

DA showed that he can get the ball in the endzone... Matt has yet to show that he can even get the ball inside the 20...

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

7/10 in the New Orleans game. Hows that hilarious if its true?

Because the game was already over? It's like hopping on the DBacks 2011 World Series bandwagon right now because of how they've played the last few weeks.

The basis of your argument is the # of chances each QB had. Leinart had hardly any shot when Warner took over. This season would have been his first year without an HoF QB on the roster. Im convinced things would have been a lot easier.

Leinart was given the starting slot in 2007, 2008, and 2010 and lost it every time. He's had plenty of chances.

 

[PJ1]

DA showed that he can get the ball in the endzone... Matt has yet to show that he can even get the ball inside the 20...

Really? If not for Beanie's fumble against the Bears Leinart gets in the endzone twice much less inside the 20.

 

[MaoTosiFanClub]

You have to admit, comparing McCown and Leinart is pretty hilarious. The respective responses and contrast to losing both just illustrates how over the top ridiculous the board has gone over it.

Actually there was a contingency that bemoaned the loss of McCown sadly.