Heard the same; they said his interview was great. His ability to identify defensive alignments have impressed many. He’ll need a line, but he’s interesting and would be much cheaper than Willis. That’s assuming they trade down and take him.
Ty Simpson declares for the 2026 NFL draft
- Thread starter Adrian
- Start date
Denny Green Fan
Registered
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2005
- Posts
- 2,471
- Reaction score
- 848
I think 12 is the lowest we can go down and for sure get him….the rams could take him at 13
OP
OP
Johnny Venerable
@JohnnyVenerable
The Arizona Cardinals are the current favorite (+150) to draft QB Ty Simpson
@JohnnyVenerable
The Arizona Cardinals are the current favorite (+150) to draft QB Ty Simpson
Denny Green Fan
Registered
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2005
- Posts
- 2,471
- Reaction score
- 848
More likely the jets at 16
Phrazbit
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2011
- Posts
- 22,462
- Reaction score
- 15,126
Gross.
I keep hearing he’s a second round prospect or a third round prospect. None of that actually matters. If he’s who you think is a franchise quarterback, you take him at 3. Logically speaking - if your team is actually run by competent football people (debatable), and you believe wholesale this is a franchise quarterback, the most valuable position on the field, you take him immediately. If you don’t, and your projection was correct that he’s a franchise quarterback, other teams are not going to let you take him. He will simply be drafted before you can get to him.
If we draft him at 3 and no other team would have touched him until round 2, then it was probably a reach. If another team was going to take him in the first round, then it was probably a good pick. If he turns into a franchise QB in 5 years, no one is going to say “well we shouldn’t have taken him at 3 because it was a reach.”
If the Cardinals truly believe he’s a franchise QB, they either take him at #3 or trade down in the top 5-10 and take him there. If they believe he’s a franchise QB, and they’re competent, meaning other competent clubs see the same thing, he doesn’t make it to #34. He won’t even make it to 12 or 15.
That doesn’t mean I’d take him, but it does lay out the logical reason why the team would spend their first on him. Having said all that, the draft is a crapshoot and these are prospects after all. If you really think your franchise QB is on the board, it would be silly to draft anyone else. I’d love to draft Bailey in the first and Simpson in the second or something like that, but that sounds much more draftnik talk than reality.
If we draft him at 3 and no other team would have touched him until round 2, then it was probably a reach. If another team was going to take him in the first round, then it was probably a good pick. If he turns into a franchise QB in 5 years, no one is going to say “well we shouldn’t have taken him at 3 because it was a reach.”
If the Cardinals truly believe he’s a franchise QB, they either take him at #3 or trade down in the top 5-10 and take him there. If they believe he’s a franchise QB, and they’re competent, meaning other competent clubs see the same thing, he doesn’t make it to #34. He won’t even make it to 12 or 15.
That doesn’t mean I’d take him, but it does lay out the logical reason why the team would spend their first on him. Having said all that, the draft is a crapshoot and these are prospects after all. If you really think your franchise QB is on the board, it would be silly to draft anyone else. I’d love to draft Bailey in the first and Simpson in the second or something like that, but that sounds much more draftnik talk than reality.
Last edited:
Simpson's going in the first round because he has potential and is in a weak QB class. In a different class, he's probably a 2nd-3rd round pick. in 2013, EJ Manuel was picked in the first round and he was a second round talent at best, but desperation kicked in for the Bills.
I dont care for Simpson as a prospect, but given the dire straits we're in for QB play, it's worth the risk to either trade back from 3 and/or trade back into the first round to pick him. It's not an endorsement of his play, but we kinda have nothing at the moment
I dont care for Simpson as a prospect, but given the dire straits we're in for QB play, it's worth the risk to either trade back from 3 and/or trade back into the first round to pick him. It's not an endorsement of his play, but we kinda have nothing at the moment
they say all qb's are crap shoots but all i saw was a crap sandwich - if he was injured and/or still needs work he should've stayed in schoil but he didn't because crap sandwiches won't be as valuable come 2027
thank you for coming to my crap talk
thank you for coming to my crap talk
Last edited:
HerefortheCards
Pretty Prince of Parties
I have this weird vision in my head of the Cards taking Love at 3 and then Simpson at 34. And then all the sudden having this young core of triplets with Love, Simpson, and Harrison like the 90’s Cowboys. Throw Trey McBride on top of that and how are they not insanely good?
Oh yeah that Cardinals curse so it will never happen.
Denny Green Fan
Registered
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2005
- Posts
- 2,471
- Reaction score
- 848
We won’t ever get him if we don’t take him at 3 or trade down not past 12 as others have said
Rams could trade up too. Then they will have the West secure for the next decade
some dumb guy
Hall of Famer
So, if the rams take him, they're set for the next decade but if the cardinals take him it's a crap shoot. I'm confused
Living up to your name, huh?
some dumb guy
Hall of Famer
So, what comes next? I'm rubber and you're glue....
I asked a question about how a player going to the rams is decade long impactful player, but that same player goes to the cardinals is most likely a bust? I was just curious. I wasn't trying to be an a-hole....just some dumb guy
HerefortheCards
Pretty Prince of Parties
The Rams have a competent front office and the Cards have the Bidwills.So, what comes next? I'm rubber and you're glue....
I asked a question about how a player going to the rams is decade long impactful player, but that same player goes to the cardinals is most likely a bust? I was just curious. I wasn't trying to be an a-hole....just some dumb guy
Ugh, just typing it out hurts.
Phrazbit
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2011
- Posts
- 22,462
- Reaction score
- 15,126
Can I get a justification for drafting this guy that isn't "If you think he's your guy, you draft him"?
Great size? No
Great arm? No
Speed? No
Accuracy? eeeeeh... no
Stats? Nope
Produces in big games? No... horrifically bad.
Can he beat out Jalen Milroe for a starting job? No
Where on earth is the logic for taking this guy in the 1st outside of pure desperation in a year without quality QB prospects?
Great size? No
Great arm? No
Speed? No
Accuracy? eeeeeh... no
Stats? Nope
Produces in big games? No... horrifically bad.
Can he beat out Jalen Milroe for a starting job? No
Where on earth is the logic for taking this guy in the 1st outside of pure desperation in a year without quality QB prospects?
LoyaltyisaCurse
IF AND WHEN HEALTHY...
Simpson is a 3rd rd talent. I can stomach a 2nd pick…sort of
LoyaltyisaCurse
IF AND WHEN HEALTHY...
There is no way Rams are taking him in 1st rd.
LoyaltyisaCurse
IF AND WHEN HEALTHY...
Harrison is in Love and a Simp for his future McBride?
Stout
A handful of fairy tales from the story bag...
It's absolutely not worth the risk. We take Simpson, and then when we suck ass and are actually in a position to draft a QB, we won't take him because we're riding with 15-start Simpson. It also extends Monti's tenure. Then a year or two later we start all over again with a new coaching staff and GM.
Stout
A handful of fairy tales from the story bag...
Bwahahahaha! I'd love it if they traded up for him, because he's a nothingburger. Then again, they'd shrug it off and somehow draft a HoF QB in the 5th round.
DVontel
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2015
- Posts
- 15,543
- Reaction score
- 29,860
Sure, but just enough.
Good arm.
Not an athletic demon, but he has wheels to him.
Yes, especially MOF, where it’s crucial in the league.
Yes, especially considering his running game was non-existent.
Who cares? Anyone remembering Mahomes producing in those *big* games in college? Josh Allen? Drake Maye? What is a big game to you? Playoffs?
Joe Burrow lost to Dwayne Haskins.
DVontel
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2015
- Posts
- 15,543
- Reaction score
- 29,860
We need to draft a 1st round player this board will hate. That way, they’ll actually turn out good. The inverse of Isaiah Simmons & maybe MHJR.
OP
OP
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
Phrazbit
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2011
- Posts
- 22,462
- Reaction score
- 15,126
None of this translates to the stats or the tape.
Dude was surrounded by 5 star recruits and somehow his teammates let him down... I just don't see it.
Jam Miller, their top running back, was averaging over 5 yards per carry prior to this season. With Ty under center he averaged 3.9... did the running backs fail Ty or did the opposition load the box because Ty is a nobody at QB?
And yeah, some of those other guys didn't put up stats in big games because they didn't play in big games because of the school they were at. Ty Simpson, in his one year, played at the premier school in the country, had several games to show his worth and he was absolute dog crap in those moments.
This is a dude you take a flier on in the 3rd ROUND (or later). Taking him with the 3rd pick is insanity.
