- Joined
- May 8, 2002
- Posts
- 1,247,147
- Reaction score
- 59
The Philadelphia Phillies have been in dire need of pitching help, and on Friday, they made a move to recall Andrew Painter from Triple-A to start against the Baltimore Orioles.
The Phillies ended up losing 6-4, resulting in their eighth loss in nine games. But it was to no fault of Painter, who tossed six solid innings, allowing two runs on three hits while striking out six.
That begs the question: did Philadelphia promote Painter to fill the Phillies' fifth starter gap? Or did they do so to showcase him before the MLB trade deadline?
Painter opened the 2026 campaign with Philadelphia's big-league club, but posted a 7.06 ERA through 14 outings before being demoted.
The former top prospect then logged a 4.56 ERA over five minor-league starts before being re-elevated to the majors.
Painter was once a top-five prospect in all of baseball, but a 2023 elbow injury that required Tommy John surgery has certainly thwarted his development.
Philadelphia Phillies pitcher Andrew Painter. Credit: Michael McLoone-Imagn Images.
That being said, Painter is still just 22 years old, and while his value may not be what it was two or three years ago, he still holds weight around baseball.
It's no secret that the Phillies are pursuing help in multiple areas before Monday's deadline. They need hitting. They need starting pitching. They need relievers.
Philly needs a little bit of everything, and while it almost certainly won't be able to properly fill all of its holes over the next two days, perhaps it can swing a blockbuster deal somewhere to bolster its playoff chances.
Painter could be the key to that. Philadelphia has a weak farm system overall, and top prospects like Aidan Miller and Aroon Escobar have watched their stock drop significantly. Miller hasn't even played in 2026 due to a back injury, and Escobar has been awful.
The Phils could look to move fellow top pitcher Gage Wood, but they would probably prefer to hold on to their 2025 first-round draft pick.
They would probably prefer to retain Painter, as well, but considering that the Phillies have committed to win-now mode (which might have been a mistake), there is no doubt that the right-hander could available before Aug. 3.
Maybe Philadelphia simply felt that Painter was ready to retake the big-league mound on Friday. Or maybe the Phillies were preparing for something else.
Continue reading...
The Phillies ended up losing 6-4, resulting in their eighth loss in nine games. But it was to no fault of Painter, who tossed six solid innings, allowing two runs on three hits while striking out six.
That begs the question: did Philadelphia promote Painter to fill the Phillies' fifth starter gap? Or did they do so to showcase him before the MLB trade deadline?
Painter opened the 2026 campaign with Philadelphia's big-league club, but posted a 7.06 ERA through 14 outings before being demoted.
The former top prospect then logged a 4.56 ERA over five minor-league starts before being re-elevated to the majors.
Painter was once a top-five prospect in all of baseball, but a 2023 elbow injury that required Tommy John surgery has certainly thwarted his development.
You must be registered for see images attach
Philadelphia Phillies pitcher Andrew Painter. Credit: Michael McLoone-Imagn Images.
That being said, Painter is still just 22 years old, and while his value may not be what it was two or three years ago, he still holds weight around baseball.
It's no secret that the Phillies are pursuing help in multiple areas before Monday's deadline. They need hitting. They need starting pitching. They need relievers.
Philly needs a little bit of everything, and while it almost certainly won't be able to properly fill all of its holes over the next two days, perhaps it can swing a blockbuster deal somewhere to bolster its playoff chances.
Painter could be the key to that. Philadelphia has a weak farm system overall, and top prospects like Aidan Miller and Aroon Escobar have watched their stock drop significantly. Miller hasn't even played in 2026 due to a back injury, and Escobar has been awful.
The Phils could look to move fellow top pitcher Gage Wood, but they would probably prefer to hold on to their 2025 first-round draft pick.
They would probably prefer to retain Painter, as well, but considering that the Phillies have committed to win-now mode (which might have been a mistake), there is no doubt that the right-hander could available before Aug. 3.
Maybe Philadelphia simply felt that Painter was ready to retake the big-league mound on Friday. Or maybe the Phillies were preparing for something else.
Continue reading...
