Brit you are optimistic about this new regime and keeping rallis which is great and often lacking on this board.
I think the reason a lot of us are negative on keeping rallis and biggest questions on him going forward are:
-the defense flat out gave up on him last year with blow out after blow out- how is rallis going to change that heading into 2026?
-the scheme of 2025 was clearly flawed, are we supposed to take some hopium and believe that rallis was being held back by JG? A good DC will adapt- but we are taking a serious leap of faith that rallis can do it
-In 3 years- which rookie has rallis developed that is ascending? Drob- average play at best but good arguments he was a bust, Melton- descending by the end of 2025, Johnson- got worse as the year continued. The list could go on - but we have serious 1st-3rd round capital draft picks who are not only not performing but seem to be getting worse. I was hopeful that we were going to bring in a new face and try to salvage this talent because I’m negative on rallis’s ability to do so.
-Lack of assistant coordinators around him- who is rallis going to hire around him now that all his assistants have left? I have my doubts that he has enough experience in the league to have developed the connections to build a competent staff- especially this late in the game.
I know I’m being a hater - but give me your thoughts on the above and what you are seeing that gives you optimism on these points.
Did the defense give up on him or did it have a lot of injuries?
Late in the season, when the tide turned from being in games and losing by a score to getting stomped we missed Will Johnson for a bunch of games, Max Melton for a bunch of games, Nolen for a bunch of games, Mack Wilson, DTD, Garrett Williams missed games. That defense was held together with string. Especially the backfield.
Drob was a bad pick, I always said he was. You can't turn crap into gold. He's actually had very few players to develop in offense heavy drafts. Outside of last year which is early to judge (although Nolen, Johnson and Burke have looked good) he's had Beej who's been injured half his time here, Garrett Williams who has been good, Pappoe, Clark and Stills, of which I'd say Stills has been good and Clark decent depth. DTD has been good. Max Melton not so much. That's a fair mix.
Have all his staff left? I know some have, but some still remain. I think he's mainly missing safeties and D line now they hired cornerbacks.
But really none of this matters because my position isn't that Rallis is great and we should defo have kept him, I've said I wouldn't have minded a new face. What I said was, it doesn't matter that we kept him because next year is a write off already and in that scenario I don't mind seeing what a 32 year old, with 3 years play calling under his belt that is considered a great young defensive mind, can do.
What's the harm? We have no QB. I hate to break this to you all, but we ain't winning the superbowl next year. There's a 98% chance we don't make the playoffs in the toughest division in football. There's a very strong chance we finish last in the division. Because, no quarterback.
That's not to say I think next year will be all gloom. I think with an improved OL and a lot of players back from injury, plus Mikes offensive scheme, that we can possibly be a .500 team, but in this division that gets you last place. I think the team will be more fun to watch and competitive in a lot of games but this is the toughest division in football and until we get a top tier QB that can play consistent football it's going to be tough. That's if Rallis can do a decent job.
With that in mind, why not give Rallis a shot out doing what he wants with his own defense? Maybe it's more of the same, in which case we lost absolutely nothing, and we finish in a good spot to draft a QB.
Or maybe he's not and we have a future star on our hands? Who knows? But there's very little downside to finding out.