Is Cardinals franchise regressing?

Stout

Hold onto the ball, Murray!
Joined
Dec 30, 2002
Posts
39,482
Reaction score
23,185
Location
Pittsburgh, PA--Enemy territory!
We can agree to disagree all day. For one thing, the defense will be much better when it comes to stopping the run. The few DL that we brought in vis FA may not be outstanding from an individual standpoint, but JG’s system of rotation will make these additions matter a ton! Who we had manning those positions last year made it impossible to not only stop the run, but to also made it impossible for the edge guys to get home too. Your edge guys are at a distinct disadvantage when your interior creates NOTHING up the middle. And as the injuries mounted on the interior, the opportunities for sacks completely went away. As pathetic as our run D became over time, this defense was literally never in 3rd and longs, which is the ideal situation for your edge guys to get more sacks. Hell, there were games late in the season when teams never ran a 3rd down play. We have very good safeties, we have a bevy of young, aggressive CB’s, and our LB play is vastly underrated. Even without Ojulari, this D will hurt people. As far as the offense is concerned, we ended up like 7th in the league in rushing, and that was with teams knowing that we had ZERO coming from the WR position. Petzing is an outstanding coordinator. He had teams guessing and being wrong with how to stop our run. Adding depth to the OL, adding MHJ, Zay Jones, a super confident Dortch, a hopefully healthier Wilson, Chris Moore, a run blocking beast in Reiman, a top 3 TE in McBride, a beast Benson to back up Conner, and a very deep RB room, and Murray poised to have an MVP like season, there’s no way that this offense won’t be elite. Of course, it’ll all hinge on Murray staying healthy for the most part. It’s OK if he misses a game or two, but he can’t have a major injury. Like any team in the NFL, the QB being healthy is paramount. I see this team winning 9-11 games, even with a brutal early schedule.
I want to engage in this discussion, but I need paragraph breaks to read this :)
 

Stout

Hold onto the ball, Murray!
Joined
Dec 30, 2002
Posts
39,482
Reaction score
23,185
Location
Pittsburgh, PA--Enemy territory!
Yeah..it's hard not to get impatient. But this year is really the first year of the build. Last year was all about tearing it down, installing the system, and tweaking the culture. This huge 12 pick draft class was the first steps towards rebuild... Paris last year, but we needed an OT anyway... we really need at least 6 of the 12 to hit...3 of 7 is usually considered an average to decent draft...so 6 of 12 is pretty good without being unrealistic expectations...
How not to rebuild a franchise lol If you can't simultaneously build year one while you're tearing it down, then you're not a competent NFL GM. The excuse making on this board is astounding.

Note: This is not saying I think Monti wasn't trying to build last year, too.
 

THESMEL

Smushdown! Take it like a fan!
Joined
May 21, 2010
Posts
5,955
Reaction score
1,128
Location
Vernon
Steves Wilkes may be available tird tumblers
 

Outerlimits

Veteran
Joined
Sep 22, 2019
Posts
424
Reaction score
941
Location
Richmond Virginia
Wouldn't it make more sense to see how the team actually does this year?

We are in year 2 of an entire new regime, and our franchise QB missed most of Year 1. Yes, we all know the later Keim years were a complete dumpster fire. Michael Bidwill letting an alcoholic who hops behind the wheel make the decisions not shockingly was disastrous.

However, it seems our new coach is really good. Plus it seems he brought in very competent staff(especially OC).

Many here mocked all the young people Gannon was choosing under him, yet the team was competitive despite a horrific roster on paper.

I'm cautiously optimistic about Monti. Sure, I can nitpick some stuff, but it is early days for him still and overall I like the strategy. I hope it works.

Main concern is obviously the defense and the ridiculously brutal schedule first half of the season
 
Last edited:

Garthshort

ASFN Addict
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Posts
9,441
Reaction score
5,592
Location
Scarsdale, NY
Unless owneership changes, I think they might pay you to keep them.
I follow the baseball Cardinals, through the St. Louis Post Dispatch, and they actually like MB, the person. He's a SLU alum and has been a supporter of various civic charities over the years. The owner they do HATE is Stan Kroenke (Rams) who really screwed the city. They are very anxious to get an NFL team. And their fans are very loyal.
 

slanidrac16

ASFN Icon
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2002
Posts
15,344
Reaction score
15,210
Location
Plainfield, Il.
Wouldn't it make more sense to see how the team actually does this year?

We are in year 2 of an entire new regime, and our franchise QB missed most of Year 1. Yes, we all know the later Keim years were a complete dumpster fire. Michael Bidwill letting an alcoholic who hops behind the wheel make the decisions not shockingly was disastrous.

However, it seems our new coach is really good. Plus it seems he brought in very competent staff(especially OC).

Many here mocked all the young people Gannon was choosing under him, yet the team was competitive despite a horrific roster on paper.

I'm cautiously optimistic about Monti. Sure, I can nitpick some stuff, but it is early days for him still and overall I like the strategy. I hope it works.

Main concern is obviously the defense and the ridiculously brutal schedule first half of the season
How soon we forget the total dumpster fire Monty took over. If we compete for a playoff spot this year it will be a terrific job.
 

PACardsFan

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
10,191
Reaction score
12,060
Location
York, PA
We get one or two really good seasons from the Cardinals each decade. Then mediocre to awful teams after that.

In the ‘90s we had Jake Plummer beating the Cowboys in the playoffs.

In the aughts we had Kurt Warner taking us to the Superbowl.

Last decade we had a loaded team with our best head coach, Bruce Arians, getting us into the playoffs a few times.

The Cardinals will probably have a brush with greatness this decade, too. I really like our current coaching staff and GM. But Michael Bidwill is a lousy owner and I don’t think he knows how to create a top tier franchise
You’re forgetting some really good teams in the 60’s (QB was Charley Johnson). We were 9-5 (1963), 9-3-2 (64), 8-5-1 (67), 9-4-1 (68). Unfortunately, we were in the same division with Cleveland & there were no wildcards back then. The 70’s had 4 really good teams under Jim Hart, winning the NFC East in 74 & 75. We missed the playoffs in 76 with a 10-4 record. But, we couldn’t sustain it because Bill Bidwill was a horrible owner and fired a good coach (Charley Winner) and a HOF coach (Coryell).

They interviewed Michael last night at halftime. He was very clear that he hired MOJG because they had the best plans to create sustained success. Whether or not they accomplish that remains to be seen, but sustained success has NEVER been a philosophical approach with this franchise. Not ever! And because of that, I’m more excited about where this organization is, and where they’re heading.
 

Cardsmasochist

Full Throttle!!
Joined
Sep 21, 2002
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
7,617
Location
Downtown Phoenix
You’re forgetting some really good teams in the 60’s (QB was Charley Johnson). We were 9-5 (1963), 9-3-2 (64), 8-5-1 (67), 9-4-1 (68). Unfortunately, we were in the same division with Cleveland & there were no wildcards back then. The 70’s had 4 really good teams under Jim Hart, winning the NFC East in 74 & 75. We missed the playoffs in 76 with a 10-4 record. But, we couldn’t sustain it because Bill Bidwill was a horrible owner and fired a good coach (Charley Winner) and a HOF coach (Coryell).

They interviewed Michael last night at halftime. He was very clear that he hired MOJG because they had the best plans to create sustained success. Whether or not they accomplish that remains to be seen, but sustained success has NEVER been a philosophical approach with this franchise. Not ever! And because of that, I’m more excited about where this organization is, and where they’re heading.
Absolutely true!

I was focusing on the team since they moved to AZ. Gene Stallings was a good coach. So was Don “Air” Coryall
 

PACardsFan

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
10,191
Reaction score
12,060
Location
York, PA
Absolutely true!

I was focusing on the team since they moved to AZ. Gene Stallings was a good coach. So was Don “Air” Coryall
Yes, Stallings was a good coach. He would have had far more success if Lomax’s career hadn’t abruptly ended when it did. Whiz was a good coach also. But, again, the Cardinals had no idea how to sustain success, so they never had a plan to replace Warner or how to build depth.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
27,827
Reaction score
38,678
Location
Colorado
Crazy how low the bar has been set and accepted by fans. The unpredictability of sports is what makes them great. Going from purposely tanking in one offseason to purposely leaving significant holes on the roster while sitting on 30 mil with a QB entering his prime is tough to tolerate. The franchise (Bidwill) just does not seem to be interested in being a franchise serious about winning.
 

BullheadCardFan

Go for it
Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2005
Posts
61,940
Reaction score
25,565
Location
Bullhead City, AZ
Crazy how low the bar has been set and accepted by fans. The unpredictability of sports is what makes them great. Going from purposely tanking in one offseason to purposely leaving significant holes on the roster while sitting on 30 mil with a QB entering his prime is tough to tolerate. The franchise (Bidwill) just does not seem to be interested in being a franchise serious about winning.
Sad, but true
 

Cbus cardsfan

Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
21,393
Reaction score
7,328
The Cardinals are different than the huge majority of NFL franchises since they are THE business of the Bidwills. Most NFL owners make a kabillion dollars in some other way and so don't worry about profit margin and spend big. Mike has certainly spent more than his Dad. But it's not like is making dough elsewhere to cover the big amount of dead money he is still paying the past coaches and GM, players. So, tighten the purse strings on current roster.

Just my view of it.
The Giants, Steelers, Colts, Raiders and even the Bengals don’t seem to have problems spending money and they’re all the family business.
 

TRW

ASFN Addict
Joined
Jan 13, 2003
Posts
7,641
Reaction score
7,149
Location
Avondale, AZ
You’re forgetting some really good teams in the 60’s (QB was Charley Johnson). We were 9-5 (1963), 9-3-2 (64), 8-5-1 (67), 9-4-1 (68). Unfortunately, we were in the same division with Cleveland & there were no wildcards back then. The 70’s had 4 really good teams under Jim Hart, winning the NFC East in 74 & 75. We missed the playoffs in 76 with a 10-4 record. But, we couldn’t sustain it because Bill Bidwill was a horrible owner and fired a good coach (Charley Winner) and a HOF coach (Coryell).

They interviewed Michael last night at halftime. He was very clear that he hired MOJG because they had the best plans to create sustained success. Whether or not they accomplish that remains to be seen, but sustained success has NEVER been a philosophical approach with this franchise. Not ever! And because of that, I’m more excited about where this organization is, and where they’re heading.
What is depressing is that the 60's and 70's were the winningest decades for this team. Each decade they had FOUR winning seasons and ONE .500 season. They've had 19 non losing seasons in the last 6 DECADES.

Pretty pathetic.
 

Garthshort

ASFN Addict
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Posts
9,441
Reaction score
5,592
Location
Scarsdale, NY
The Giants, Steelers, Colts, Raiders and even the Bengals don’t seem to have problems spending money and they’re all the family business.
Well the Mara's (Giants) were in the same boat as us. They sold a half interest in the team to the Tisch family, who are super rich. So, now they have all the money that they need.
 

PACardsFan

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
10,191
Reaction score
12,060
Location
York, PA
What is depressing is that the 60's and 70's were the winningest decades for this team. Each decade they had FOUR winning seasons and ONE .500 season. They've had 19 non losing seasons in the last 6 DECADES.

Pretty pathetic.
Very depressing indeed. They consistently had good to great OL’s in the 60’s & 70’s. I’ve been following this team for an eternity, and I can count on one hand how many good defenses they’ve had. The closest thing to a great D they had was wasted when we had to play Lindley down the stretch & into the playoffs. If Palmer had stayed healthy, that team (2014?) was better than the 2015 team & could have gone very deep into the playoffs.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
27,827
Reaction score
38,678
Location
Colorado
The toughest part for fans is that it takes time for a franchise to establish credibility when they have been as awful as the Cardinals have been. Reputation, wins, stability, and a willingness to spend are some hallmarks of top franchises. If Monti and Gannon are still around in 8 years, and their tenure in AZ is above a .500 win rate...that's when this convo changes.

Up to this point, there are always "buts" that accompany any improvement which are deserved. A lot of this is because much of the Cardinals success almost comes by accident. Warner. Arians. Kliff/Keim playoff appearance. All seem like probability outliers vs actual planned moves which led to success.
 

oaken1

Stone Cold
Supporting Member
Banned from P+R
Joined
Mar 13, 2004
Posts
17,740
Reaction score
15,267
Location
Modesto, California
The toughest part for fans is that it takes time for a franchise to establish credibility when they have been as awful as the Cardinals have been. Reputation, wins, stability, and a willingness to spend are some hallmarks of top franchises. If Monti and Gannon are still around in 8 years, and their tenure in AZ is above a .500 win rate...that's when this convo changes.

Up to this point, there are always "buts" that accompany any improvement which are deserved. A lot of this is because much of the Cardinals success almost comes by accident. Warner. Arians. Kliff/Keim playoff appearance. All seem like probability outliers vs actual planned moves which led to success.
Yeah... it's the whole. Blind squirrel/Nut thing with a Bidwill in charge.
 

FB94

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Jan 2, 2019
Posts
3,685
Reaction score
4,735
Location
Anthem
We’ve had coaches who have had success over a window of time but it always seems to be in very short blocks. Is that on the coach not Being able to adapt, combined with poor front office performance keeping team growth going. JG and MO have injected some positive attributes thus far, but real test is if they can keep getting better year over year, and show consistent results. Would like nothing more than a 10 year run with the cards staying ahead of the curve. I think the new staff and front office still have a bit of a honeymoon period for this year, but year three is the first real marker for me.
 

Totally_Red

Air Raid Warning!
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Posts
8,778
Reaction score
4,486
Location
Iowa
I really like the MOJG team and am hopeful that the sustained success stuff is real. The build through the draft model has worked well in GB.

If JG puts together a good season the Cardinals will be a more preferred FA destination instead of one where you have to overpay to attract and sign top tier talent.
 

ajcardfan

I see you.
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
38,116
Reaction score
24,428
I really like the MOJG team and am hopeful that the sustained success stuff is real. The build through the draft model has worked well in GB.

If JG puts together a good season the Cardinals will be a more preferred FA destination instead of one where you have to overpay to attract and sign top tier talent.
If they want sustained success then this needs to be a real playoff contending, or playoff bound, year. Personally, I think another 4-13 season, 5-12, etc, will totally take the wind out of the sails. It will mean we have a QB issue and draft picks who are not doing well. So what if we have strong draft position in 2025? We had a great draft picks value in 2024 also. Free agents won't be expecting the next draft here to do much. "Same old Cardinals". That will be what free agents think of this franchise if we bomb yet another season.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
549,590
Posts
5,368,887
Members
6,307
Latest member
jgreendtc
Top