Film Study: What Carson Beck brings to the Arizona Cardinals

[Cardinal88]

Agree but there are some that try and back up statements with facts instead of stating things with absolute certainty with no factual basis.
I get it though.

I'll say this with only the eye test and what I've seen, if Carson Beck is a starter in the NFL, he will have beaten very long odds and changed to be a real QB.

If he had 1st round talent, he'd have went in round 1. He's a lottery ticket and people thinking he should be starting are buying things based on wining the powerball.
Not very smart.

He hasn't even played yet! Cut the dude some slack!

I know a lot of the posters take their opinions and slam Beck like he's some high school player. The fact of the matter is, he was considered to be a top 1st round talent if he came out in 2025 but no.... he messed up his UCL in the SEC Championship Game which required at least an 8 month recovery. He came back at the beginning of the season I think and was playing for Miami. I'm sure he had to strengthen the elbow back up.

But if all of the neisayers want to continue to slam the dude, I guess we got no answers for you all!

By the way, if Beck falls on his face and doesn't work out at all, it is not even close to Monte's worse selection. Right now, I'd say that could be a toss up between the 4th and/or the 27th plck in the 2024 draft. Neither of these two have shown they are worthy of a 1st round selection. Beck was a 3rd round where you take some flyers on.

 

[kerouac9]

The fact of the matter is, he was considered to be a top 1st round talent if he came out in 2025

Citation needed here

 

[Phrazbit]

In big moments he makes the absolute worst decisions. He is an interception machine in the clutch.

I don’t think he’s ready to be a starter, I don’t think he will ever be ready to be a starter. If he plays, I feel bad for our receivers with all the hospital balls he is going to throw, and likely interceptions they are going to have to try to break up.

 

[LoyaltyisaCurse]

Via ChatGPT:

Citation needed here

ESPN projects Carson Beck to go No. 1 in 2025 NFL draft

Will Georgia Bulldogs quarterback Carson Beck go No. 1 in the 2025 NFL draft?

sports.yahoo.com

Georgia football: ESPN 2025 1st-round mock draft has Carson Beck at No. 1 overall, includes three Dawgs

Three Bulldogs get first-round projections from the ESPN NFL Draft analyst. Georgia is set to face one team this fall that also has three projected first-round picks.

247sports.com

Georgia Bulldog Predicted to Be No.1 Overall Pick in 2025 NFL Draft

According to this way too early mock draft, this Georgia Bulldog will be the first player selected in the 2025 NFL Draft.

www.si.com

 

[Phrazbit]

Via ChatGPT:

ESPN projects Carson Beck to go No. 1 in 2025 NFL draft

Will Georgia Bulldogs quarterback Carson Beck go No. 1 in the 2025 NFL draft?

sports.yahoo.com

Georgia football: ESPN 2025 1st-round mock draft has Carson Beck at No. 1 overall, includes three Dawgs

Three Bulldogs get first-round projections from the ESPN NFL Draft analyst. Georgia is set to face one team this fall that also has three projected first-round picks.

247sports.com

Georgia Bulldog Predicted to Be No.1 Overall Pick in 2025 NFL Draft

According to this way too early mock draft, this Georgia Bulldog will be the first player selected in the 2025 NFL Draft.

www.si.com

All of these projections are a year ahead of the draft (also 2 of those are referencing the same original article).

By the time the draft came around in each year there was not even the slightest chance he'd go early, and so he perpetually remained in college until he couldn't. If he had ANOTHER year, I'm sure he'd still playing college football.

He gloated about how he didn't attend classes last year at Miami.

He's like Matt Leinart, only dumber, less talented, older (when they were drafted), a weaker arm and with far less success.

 

[Stout]

Agree but there are some that try and back up statements with facts instead of stating things with absolute certainty with no factual basis.
I get it though.

I'll say this with only the eye test and what I've seen, if Carson Beck is a starter in the NFL, he will have beaten very long odds and changed to be a real QB.

If he had 1st round talent, he'd have went in round 1. He's a lottery ticket and people thinking he should be starting are buying things based on wining the powerball.
Not very smart.

The reason I would want him to start a significant number of games is the fact-driven logic of understanding how stupid and backwards thinking this organization is. I guarantee you that if he doesn't get a long look this season, Monti will be stupid enough to pass on a QB because we have to "see what we have" in Beck. I'm not about even giving Monti that kind of a chance. Granted, he shouldn't be back next season, but does anyone really believe Monti's on the hot seat?