For Those Questioning Reiman’s Value

[Bkbobo]

Did they mention what's Tip injury?

 

[daves]

Did they mention what's Tip injury?

Says here, "foot injury".

 

[Chopper0080]

TR is out.

We are going to get blown out.

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

Vokolek slander will not be tolerated

 

[Jay Cardinal]

Any Tip Reiman highlight videos at NFL? I would think there should be some. I think he had a big block last week that set the edge for Benson’s big run.

 

[BooksOrangePlanet]

has this issue been resolved

 

[602 Native]

We put up 27 pts without TR that is a miracle.

 

[Cheesebeef]

We put up 27 pts without TR that is a miracle.

The D scored a TD. The Offense put up 20 points. Against a pathetic D.

 

[Cardiac]

The D scored a TD. The Offense put up 20 points. Against a pathetic D.

I would argue 10 points with the pick in FG range. So my math is 17 points by the offense. Hell, Dortch put us in FG range with his excellent punt return.

 

[Cheesebeef]

I would argue 10 points with the pick in FG range. So my math is 17 points by the offense. Hell, Dortch put us in FG range with his excellent punt return.

Wouldn’t argue against that either.

 

[602 Native]

Imagine what we will do with the offensive powerhouse back in the lineup.

 

[Chopper0080]

Imagine what we will do with the offensive powerhouse back in the lineup.

Kyler said that he felt Tip being out and the offense lacking it's enforcer.

 

[602 Native]

Kyler said that he felt Tip being out and the offense lacking it's enforcer.

Hes a blocking TE that we spent a 3rd rounder on and don't have a single WR that is worth a damn so far.

 

[Cheesebeef]

Kyler said that he felt Tip being out and the offense lacking it's enforcer.

Our top 6 pick LT, who we traded down for to pass on a likely HOF Pass Rusher should be the damn offense’s enforcer, kicking people’s ass.

 

[TJ]

Kyler said that he felt Tip being out and the offense lacking it's enforcer.

Drew wants Tip back so he can give 2 of MHJ's 4 targets to him.

 

[kerouac9]

Our top 6 pick LT, who we traded down for to pass on a likely HOF Pass Rusher should be the damn offense’s enforcer, kicking people’s ass.

This seems a little premature

Love the argument tho

 

[DVontel]

This seems a little premature

Love the argument tho

Maybe

Who is to say we’re still not looking for a LT?

 

[MadCardDisease]

Maybe

Who is to say we’re still not looking for a LT?

PJJ stonewalled everything that the Saints and Panthers threw at him in the first two games of the season. He had a perfect 100% pass block win rate in week 1. Why would the Cardinals be looking for a LT? Seems like the last thing they need to be worried about at this point.

 

[DVontel]

PJJ stonewalled everything that the Saints and Panthers threw at him in the first two games of the season. He had a perfect 100% pass block win rate in week 1. Why would the Cardinals be looking for a LT? Seems like the last thing they need to be worried about at this point.

Yea I know.

You’re not understanding the context. If we drafted Will Anderson, who is to say we’re still not looking for an LT?

 

[kerouac9]

Maybe

Who is to say we’re still not looking for a LT?

I dunno. A mid starting LT looks a lot like PJJ. A mid edge looks a lot like Baron Browning.

You can scheme around having a mid LT — we’re already doing a lot of it with our multi-TE setup (intentionally or not). Having a mid edge stresses the rest of your defense.

If we’d taken Anderson we’d probably still have the Captain. Maybe today we have Jonah Williams at LT and Guyton at RT.

If PJJ were going to become Joe Thomas it would probably have happened by now. He’s a very good LT you don’t have to worry about or look to replace. Safe pick for Monti who couldn’t afford to blow that first selection. Not mad about it but obviously you hope for a guy who has a career arc better than “maybe he’ll make three pro bowls before all is said and done” when you rightfully earn the #2 overall pick in the draft.

 

[DVontel]

probably still have the Captain.

After the injury? At his best, has he even been just as good as PJJ?

Maybe today we have Jonah Williams at LT and Guyton at RT.

This is scary. Jesus Christ.

If PJJ were going to become Joe Thomas it would probably have happened by now. He’s a very good LT you don’t have to worry about or look to replace. Safe pick for Monti who couldn’t afford to blow that first selection. Not mad about it but obviously you hope for a guy who has a career arc better than “maybe he’ll make three pro bowls before all is said and done” when you rightfully earn the #2 overall pick in the draft.

We all wish he was Joe Thomas or Lane Johnson or Trent Williams, but I’m still good with a very good/borderline great LT. Especially in a division with Nick Bosa, Jared Verse, & a plethora of Seattle’s EDGEs.

 

[MadCardDisease]

Yea I know.

You’re not understanding the context. If we drafted Will Anderson, who is to say we’re still not looking for an LT?

Got it! That makes more sense.

 

[ASUCHRIS]

After the injury? At his best, has he even been just as good as PJJ?

Yes? It's obviously early but PJJ looks like a very good tackle but not a star, just like Hump. When you have a top 5 pick, you're trying to draft a star, and Anderson Jr. has been that. So far, the Texans are winning the deal.

 

[DVontel]

It's obviously early but PJJ looks like a very good tackle but not a star, just like Hump

I remember Hump being just a *good* player. Never a *very good* player like PJJ, but I digress.

 

[BigDavis75]

Yes? It's obviously early but PJJ looks like a very good tackle but not a star, just like Hump. When you have a top 5 pick, you're trying to draft a star, and Anderson Jr. has been that. So far, the Texans are winning the deal.

Hes looked really good, I feel like people on here undersell him just because Anderson may be better.

 

[kerouac9]

Hes looked really good, I feel like people on here undersell him just because Anderson may be better.

The distinctions between a good and really good LT are hard to pinpoint. But there’s a huge gap between very good and elite.

For a first pick under a new regime, PJJ I think is going to work out. Much better to take a safe pick from a production and character standpoint. Very similar with Charmin. It’s still frustrating to have left excess value on the table.

I also think Charmin has underperformed PJJ, but he plays a more dependent position.