How much would u give up for Carson Palmer?

[Totally_Red]

Poll coming with several choices

 

[Dr. Jones]

5th or 6th IMO

 

[unseenaz]

Wouldn't spend any picks on him, then we're investing more than just money into the guy.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

Wouldn't give up any 2013 picks...only conditional 5-7 round 2014 pick.

 

[Goldfield]

Best QB available. Our biggest need... I would give up to a 5th without question. I doubt it would take more that that to get him. But if it took a 4th I would consider that also.

We need a QB badly.

 

[Chopper0080]

I would give up one of our 6th rounders this year at most. Possibly a higher 2014 draft pick if it was very conditional, but in no way would I give up multiple picks.

Normally I would say no picks, just wait until he is cut, but in this case, we are signing Palmer to compete this year and I want him in the building as quickly as possible.

 

[az jam]

6th round from this year and a conditional one for 2014 based on performance, like a 6th becoming a 5th.

 

[ARZCardinals]

Unless he's getting an incentive based contract I don't want him

His value is around 5-6 mill + incentives

Got hosed too big with Kolb to forget

Wait till he's released

If he takes the deal fine if not forget him and live with Stanton

 

[Arizona_Steve]

Looks like Flynn to Oakland has been finalized, so a much greater chance that Palmer is cut now.

 

[BullheadCardFan]

The Raiders also are trying to finalize a trade that will send Carson Palmer to the Arizona Cardinals for minimal compensation, sources said.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/9...ree-trade-seattle-seahawks-matt-flynn-sources

 

[CardsFan88]

I voted for 4th or 5th round...because I WOULD be willing to give that up for him.

That said, I still think we play hardball for a 6th, 7th, or even wait for him to be released. The Raiders are in no position to ask for a 4th or 5th round, so you don't offer that.

He's definitely worth a 4th or 5th.

 

[Duckjake]

5,6,7 what do those picks matter anyway? Almost none of the guys selected in those rounds will last more than 2-4 years, won't ever be starters and aren't really much better than UDFA's you can pick up.

Who have we had? Reggie Wells back in 2003 is the only guy I could find who was a starter and last more than 3-4 years.

It's almost the same as getting Palmer for nothing.

And for you guys who can't wait to post a picture of Tom Brady, Kurt Warner was an UDFA

 

[Shane]

5,6,7 what do those picks matter anyway? Almost none of the guys selected in those rounds will last more than 2-4 years, won't ever be starters and aren't really much better than UDFA's you can pick up.

Who have we had? Reggie Wells back in 2003 is the only guy I could find who was a starter and last more than 3-4 years.

It's almost the same as getting Palmer for nothing.

And for you guys who can't wait to post a picture of Tom Brady, Kurt Warner was an UDFA

I LOVE YOU!

 

[Totally_Red]

5,6,7 what do those picks matter anyway? Almost none of the guys selected in those rounds will last more than 2-4 years, won't ever be starters and aren't really much better than UDFA's you can pick up.

Who have we had? Reggie Wells back in 2003 is the only guy I could find who was a starter and last more than 3-4 years.

It's almost the same as getting Palmer for nothing.

And for you guys who can't wait to post a picture of Tom Brady, Kurt Warner was an UDFA

Next you're going to tell me John Skelton wasn't worth Bryant McFadden and a 5th round pick. You can't really think Carson Palmer is a better quarterback than John Skelton?

 

[NashDishesDimes]

4th or 5th at the most. Not sure why most of you wouldn't give that up. That still is a low-risk very high reward situation. If hes awful, they lose a 4th or 5th who would have probably been a role-player at best. If he pans out, Cards compete in the best division in football.

Have to take risk in this league