We seem to go through this every year.
It really depends who the DC is. I thought Gannon/Rallis used him poorly. Budda might be one of the worst ball playing safeties in the league. There were some plays in coverage at deep safety last year where he got embarrassed. He should never be at free safety.
But get a DC who will use him in the box and I don't think there's anyone better. I'd even go as far to say that Budda, despite his size, can be a hybrid safety/linebacker in sub packages where you want more DBs on the field. He's that good a tackler and reader of the game.
TBF to Vance Joseph there was a lot of things I didn't like about his defense but the way he used Budda was spot on.
My instinct is to trade a 30 year old safety, but I fear we wouldn't get much and he'd go to a team that would use him right and we'd look like fools.
With JT gone (at last, so overrated) we should put Budda at strong and Rabbit at free (when we line up that way).
Also, I don't want to undermine a new HC by taking away one of the few stars on the team. Doesn't send the right message. Unless they want a player swap. Budda for DJ Moore?