Should Carson Palmer be in the discussions for MVP?

[Hollywood]

I mean....Jeff Fisher....Pete Carroll...Jim Harbaugh....or our lovely Bruce.

I would have never thought I would ask that question with the thought that the answer is Arians; however Fisher is doing a heck of a job.

I will admit that I started to doubt Fishers ability.

 

[desertdawg]

I think Dawg is a pretty cool passionate fan who bleeds Cardinal red and sometimes gets out of control and I can safely say that 99.9% of us each week are like ,"dang it Dawg, that could get you banned!" because we luv the dawg a ton here and when he is not around it sux

Much love amigo!

 

[Jim Otis]

We are halfway 7 and 1 , we are 5 and 0 with Palmer at QB , so much depends on the second half of the season . If the winning continues , then certainly he should be considered for both league and team .

 

[desertdawg]

We are halfway 7 and 1 , we are 5 and 0 with Palmer at QB , so much depends on the second half of the season . If the winning continues , then certainly he should be considered for both league and team .

I think Stanton winning 2 games hurts his chances, it shows that the team is a team, but I agree Palmer has been a pimp. Even more so once Veldheer got here.

 

[Cardiac]

I'm not worried about "cred" here. You can put your cred where your boyfriend parks his penis.

And I never drink...ever.

Wow, MOD's asleep at the wheel tonight.

Seriously this guy needs a time out.

Kudo's Dawg for staying classy.

 

[Zeno]

I mean....Jeff Fisher....Pete Carroll...Jim Harbaugh....or our lovely Bruce.

I would have never thought I would ask that question with the thought that the answer is Arians; however Fisher is doing a heck of a job.

Fisher is easily the worst HC in the division, he is one of the most overrated HCs in the NFL.

 

[Zeno]

I mean....Jeff Fisher....Pete Carroll...Jim Harbaugh....or our lovely Bruce.

I would have never thought I would ask that question with the thought that the answer is Arians; however Fisher is doing a heck of a job.

Fisher is easily the worst HC in the division, he is one of the most overrated HCs in the NFL.

 

[New Username]

Wow, MOD's asleep at the wheel tonight.

Seriously this guy needs a time out.

Kudo's Dawg for staying classy.

If that is out of line then I apologize. But after watching desert dawg postings I figured it was within the margins of good fun. I'll tone it down. He has me on ignore anyway.

 

[Cardiac]

If that is out of line then I apologize. But after watching desert dawg postings I figured it was within the margins of good fun. I'll tone it down. He has me on ignore anyway.

The dark side does call to Dawg at times so I get what you are saying. Thing is gay stuff is outdated and simply wrong and you seemed to be on a mission to get the Dawg fired up.

Looks like everyone is cool now so let's get back to talking FB.

CP has a long way to go to get the league MVP but my real and only concern is that the Cards keep winning and they get home field advantage throughout the playoffs.

 

[gmabel830]

Palmer won't be in the discussion for MVP, and outside of Arians none of our people will be in the discussion for any major awards (Bowles deserves coordinator of the year award, but that's not a formal/major one that I know of). This team is the ultimate whole is greater than the sum of their parts situation. On one of the radio stations a couple of weeks ago, they were discussing at that point in time who would be a Pro Bowler if it happened then -- and only could come up with Catanzaro.

We've have multiple receivers all put up decent but not huge numbers.
Ellington started a little slow with the foot injury.
Multiple QB's in there.
O-line has been solid but doesn't really have any huge names that will get attention.

Campbell has been hurt, and the rest of the front 7 are hard workers without name value.
Secondary has been good, but a lot of depth back there and Peterson is the only one with huge name recognition but has been incosistent this year.

I think we'll get our due with Pro Bowl nods given how good the team is, but I could easily see a lot of very deserving players get overlooked due to the amazing depth we have on our roster and the fact that different guys are stepping up week in and week out.

 

[FArting]

Yes

 

[Redheart]

Fisher is easily the worst HC in the division, he is one of the most overrated HCs in the NFL.

The guy did just take his team, minus their starting QB, into SF and be the niners.

 

[Zeno]

The guy did just take his team, minus their starting QB, into SF and be the niners.

So? 2 1/2 year record in STL 7-8-1, 7-9, 3-5 -- 17 wins in 3 seasons

Arians has 17 wins in a season and a half.

Harbaugh has a .723 winning pct

Carroll just won the Super Bowl and has been to the playoffs 3 of his 4 yrs in Seattle.

 

[Mulli]

So? 2 1/2 year record in STL 7-8-1, 7-9, 3-5 -- 17 wins in 3 seasons

Arians has 17 wins in a season and a half.

Harbaugh has a .723 winning pct

Carroll just won the Super Bowl and has been to the playoffs 3 of his 4 yrs in Seattle.

This!

 

[kerouac9]

No, but Ellington deserves to be in the conversation.

Ellington is so much more important to the success of the Arizona Cardinals offense than Carson Palmer.

That said, neither are as valuable as Rivers/Manning/Brady/Rodgers are to their teams' success.

 

[Iceman]

Can't see him being an option. Cards keep winning, may see him as a Pro Bowl candidate, but thats it. IMO

 

[New Username]

Fisher is easily the worst HC in the division, he is one of the most overrated HCs in the NFL.

That was probably worth saying, but not twice.