OT: Wild Card weekend. 1/14/23-1/16/23

[RON_IN_OC]

Brock Purdy has better coaching than Kyler

FTFY

 

[pemory09]

Turned on the Hawks-9ers in the 3rd. Refs too involved, shut it off. Looking forward to Bolts-Jags however; should be a good one…unless the zebras get too involved—something they seem to love to do.

 

[DVontel]

FTFY

Folks trying to get likes & their rocks hard when they say that.

Not even just coaching either, look at the overall surplus in talent not just compared to us, but a good amount of other teams in the league.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

Tranquil quieted the crowd with that pick.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

That didn't take long. TD Chargers.

 

[blindseyed]

Rough start for the Jags

 

[Redsz]

For those of us that want Sean Payton we all need to be Charger fans today.

 

[pemory09]

The Chargers. A postseason team that we should have beaten.

 

[pemory09]

Jags going for it.

 

[pemory09]

Ummmmm…another pick.

 

[pemory09]

Is KK calling the plays for Jax tonight?

 

[RON_IN_OC]

San D I E G O, Super Chargers!

 

[Shane]

FTFY

Ehhh Purdy is Mr. Irrelevant. Kyler is the overall #1 pick Transcendent talent Heisman trophy winner.

Not saying coaching doesn’t help it obviously does and can. But Purdy definitely appears to be the more polished player and that’s after only starting 7 NFL games. Just from Kylers starting point and hype alone he should be the more polished player even with no coaching.

Coaching aside it’s quite amazing that this kid had 332 yards and 3 TDs in his first playoff game. We can only hope Kyler can accomplish that someday at this point.

Heck Kyler hasn’t even had a 30 passing TD season but Geno freaking Smith has…

 

[DVontel]

Ehhh Purdy is Mr. Irrelevant. Kyler is the overall #1 pick Transcendent talent Heisman trophy winner.

Not saying coaching doesn’t help it obviously does and can. But Purdy definitely appears to be the more polished player and that’s after only starting 7 NFL games. Just from Kylers starting point and hype alone he should be the more polished player even with no coaching.

Coaching aside it’s quite amazing that this kid had 332 yards and 3 TDs in his first playoff game. We can only hope Kyler can accomplish that someday at this point.

Heck Kyler hasn’t even had a 30 passing TD season but Geno freaking Smith has…

You gonna ignore the crazy difference in talent too? You purposely doing that?

I expect a usual Shane reply of “Stop making excuses of Kyler” or something of that nature when this is less about Kyler & more about the overall team structure of talent the 49ers possess.

 

[Brian in Mesa]

Brock Purdy is better than Kyler

Yep, I said it recently, too.

Fantastic playoff debut.

Local kid (born in Queen Creek, AZ, and went to high school in Gilbert) doing great so far in his NFL career.

 

[Shane]

You gonna ignore the crazy difference in talent too? You purposely doing that?

I expect a usual Shane reply of “Stop making excuses of Kyler” or something of that nature when this is less about Kyler & more about the overall team structure of talent the 49ers possess.

Clearly they’re a better team top to bottom. Who’s arguing that?

But 235 million dollar Kyler should still be more polished then Purdy(Mr freaking irrelevant) year 4 in the league. No questions asked.

 

[SoonerLou]

Maybe, but at least Murphy has proven to be a productive/good player.

It’s not even in the same galaxy as Isabella over DK. Hell, it’s not even worse than Simmons over Wirfs.

Targeting a DB after drafting your QTOF is the kind of incompetence that set the table for taking Simmons over Wirfs.

The Bengals smartly drafted Tee Higgins at the top of round 2 after selecting Burrow #1.

However, you dont draft a nickel corner when your WR room was either old or bad the year before.

There is no Isabella pick if you draft a Wr at he top of round 2.

Respect to Murphy, but Keim had no clue.

 

[DVontel]

Targeting a DB after drafting your QTOF is the kind of incompetence that set the table for taking Simmons over Wirfs.

Difference is Byron has shown to be a good player. Simmons has not. I don’t disagree with you fully, but it’s not as black & white as you are implying.

 

[DVontel]

Clearly they’re a better team top to bottom. Who’s arguing that?

You completely just skipping over it. Stop acting like I’m a damn moron, Shane.

But 235 million dollar Kyler should still be more polished then Purdy(Mr freaking irrelevant) year 4 in the league. No questions asked.

Kyler should be better than he is, but luckily he won’t have a GM actively sabotaging his & his teammates career anymore.

 

[SoonerLou]

Difference is Byron has shown to be a good player. Simmons has not. I don’t disagree with you fully, but it’s not as black & white as you are implying.

PFF isnt the end all be all, but Im not sure Murphy's ever been out of the 60s. He's been decent and played really well at times this year. He's closer to Simmons than people want to admit (career wise).

Edit: Simmons looks worse obviously cause he was a top 10 pick.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[SoonerLou]

Brock Purdy must be better than Trevor Lawrence as well.
Trevor has 3 ints, Purdy had 4 tds.

Doesnt matter what Trevor might have done or would have done with the 49ers. Purdy is better. End of discussion.

 

[Shane]

You completely just skipping over it. Stop acting like I’m a damn moron, Shane.

Kyler should be better than he is, but luckily he won’t have a GM actively sabotaging his & his teammates career anymore.

I’m not skipping over anything. Anyone with half a brain can see that. It’s still irrelevant the fact that Mr irrelevant 705K a year looks light years more composed and under control then our #1 overall 1/4 billion dollar man.

In fact because he has that contract and loads more talent he should be expected to overcome some of the talent deficiency around him. Many QBs have over the years.

But sure let’s just blame Keim for ALL of Kylers issues. You’re starting to sound like PA.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

Asante is en fuego.

 

[DVontel]

PFF isnt the end all be all,

Correct.

Going by eye-test, I don’t remember Byron having a standout bad game while it seems like Simmons has one every other game.

If Byron is decent, Simmons is mediocre.