2008 Draft order...

[Shogun]

I know I haven't followed college football a ton this year, but who?

No offense. Jon Stewart could be a nice prospect for all I care. He is nowhere near as talented as McFadden, though. I wasn't sold on Bush coming out, or Tomlinson, or even necessarily on AP. Seeing McFadden, though, I am almost 100 percent certain that, barring injury, he will be a HOF back.

I wanted to let this slide, but I just can't...

First of all, how can you say that Stewart is nowhere near as talented when you haven't seen him play?! I personally think there really isn't a massive disparity between the two as many would have you think - much like the Peterson v. Lynch debates last year. I've watched Stewart for a long while.

Watch Stewart play - or at least some highlights - he'll blow you away. He's a T10 pick on talent alone, but will slip because of the offense he's in. He has elite back written all over him. Like pre-injury Fred Taylor good.

 

[Goober Man]

Why when you can get Jon Stewart cheaper?

Or we could get Tashard Choice in the 3rd Round

 

[Stout]

I wanted to let this slide, but I just can't...

First of all, how can you say that Stewart is nowhere near as talented when you haven't seen him play?! I personally think there really isn't a massive disparity between the two as many would have you think - much like the Peterson v. Lynch debates last year. I've watched Stewart for a long while.

Watch Stewart play - or at least some highlights - he'll blow you away. He's a T10 pick on talent alone, but will slip because of the offense he's in. He has elite back written all over him. Like pre-injury Fred Taylor good.

That is a fair point indeed, and I will withhold judgment until I see some highlights of his. Still, I seriously doubt anyone will play better in the NFL than McFadden. He's just a complete stud, with the speed and the power.

 

[Shogun]

That is a fair point indeed, and I will withhold judgment until I see some highlights of his. Still, I seriously doubt anyone will play better in the NFL than McFadden. He's just a complete stud, with the speed and the power.

That funny, so is Stewart for the exact same reasons.

 

[Cardsmasochist]

Do we really want to see McFadden in Cowboy gear?

Aren't the Cowboys picking in the late 20's? If so, how would McFadden still be on the board? Or do you think they will trade up to get him?

 

[slanidrac16]

I just caught a few minutes of the Oregon game. Stewart has about 250yds. He reminds me a bit of Maurice Jones Drew......which isn't a bad thing.

 

[NightHawk11and81]

McFadden wasn't close to that at the Cotton Bowl today. I was at the game in Dallas, and we did a nice job neutralizing McFadden, although he did still go for 105 yards and a score. But he wasn't anywhere near the best running back on the field today. Tony Temple was unbelievable for Missouri.

As a disclaimer, in no way am I suggesting we should pick Temple, or that McFadden's overrated, or that Temple's the better player overall. But on this day, he was.

 

[okcardzona]

Nighthawk ,Congratulations on your Missouri Tigers win.