How did Keim do his job? He let our best, most impactful young player on the defense walk for a 1 year deal. His big ticket signing was on a guy who can’t stay healthy. His other big ticket was on a WR who looks like he doesn’t really care about football. He “fixed” the kicker spot by signing one mediocre guy to replace another. His draft picks have been almost completely busts. His goal was to go out and get leaders and failed. He went another year with his handpicked DC who isn’t all that.
He made two good trades to get Ertz and Hudson and some good 1 year cheap pick ups, but He established no foundation for the future because anyone we do have that played well this year will be a FA and didnt sign any of them to an extension. In our ALL IN off-season, it looks like we MIGHT get a wild card loss and more questions than answers for the future.
Overall, in a make it or break it year we’re looking at an immediate return of okay but bleak for the future. That’s a solid C grade, as far as I’m concerned.