- Joined
- May 14, 2002
- Posts
- 97,819
- Reaction score
- 50,598
Fair enough some people are saying you can get two picks including a first rounder for Marvin Harrison Jr and also replace him with Wan’dale Robinson.
Yes and I still believe that.
Fair enough some people are saying you can get two picks including a first rounder for Marvin Harrison Jr and also replace him with Wan’dale Robinson.
Oh, I don’t think anyone is giving up 2 picks for Charmin. He looks like a dog with fleas. And to be honest, at this point, after 2 years, with zero 1000 yard seasons under his belt, I doubt we’d even get a first for him now. Maybe a 2nd but book is out on him physically and mentally, IMO.Yes and I still believe that.
Oh, I don’t think anyone is giving up 2 picks for Charmin. He looks like a dog with fleas. And to be honest, at this point, after 2 years, with zero 1000 yard seasons under his belt, I doubt we’d even get a first for him now. Maybe a 2nd but book is out on him physically and mentally, IMO.
Why is there any discussion about possibly trading MHJ? Once JB took over QB, Marv suddenly got more targets and looks much better than before. Just because his appendix quit him doesn't mean the cards should. That's "Bidwill" thinking...trade one of your best players to get...what? A "hope I pick a better player"...come on, you guys are much smarter than this
I understand your thinking. I'm just saying let's wait and see how he does when he comes back with JB throwing as much as he has been. If he doesn't start looking like a WR1, then this discussion will be validUnless it was because of the appendix, which is possible, the last game he played he had 12 targets and 3 catches. Dallas' defense is horrible, judging him off that game is like judging him on the first rams game his rookie year where he destroyed their #5 and #6 CB and we all thought ok this is the kid we thought we drafted.
I understand your thinking. I'm just saying let's wait and see how he does when he comes back with JB throwing as much as he has been. If he doesn't start looking like a WR1, then this discussion will be valid
Funny as hell.Oh, I don’t think anyone is giving up 2 picks for Charmin. He looks like a dog with fleas. And to be honest, at this point, after 2 years, with zero 1000 yard seasons under his belt, I doubt we’d even get a first for him now. Maybe a 2nd but book is out on him physically and mentally, IMO.
Maybe in the open market but he’s getting the money early. 3 for $40 is a good deal if you control him for the next four.
i think the OC bears equal responsibilityI think this shows how QBs can impact young WRs. Something to file away for sure.
I think this shows how QBs can impact young WRs. Something to file away for sure.
Probably held back Nuk also. Was more efficient on same targets and receptions in 2018 with Watson.Any WR. Look at Justin Jefferson this year. He's only had 100 yards twice, and both were with Wentz.
I said this about Kirk. I've said it about Mike and Marv. Kyler has been limiting WR output for years for everyone except Nuk.
First-round picks are different tho. If MikeWilly wants to bet on himself at $1.5 million in 2026 more power to him.People don't take less than the market price to go early. This is a fan myth. Especially as the money isn't early.
Think the Nuk one is a bit of a reach. The best year with Kyler wasn’t a career year, but it was a standard Nuk year.Probably held back Nuk also. Was more efficient on same targets and receptions in 2018 with Watson.
We’ll never really know about the Zays Jones and Hollywoods Brown.Mike Wilson is really the only WR you can make a legitimate case that Kyler has held back severly. McBride too once they’re near the endzone
Kirk had that one career year in Duval, then never came close to that again.
Marv has had the same problems with Jacoby as with Kyler(mental lapses, drops).
Mike Wilson is really the only WR you can make a legitimate case that Kyler has held back severly. McBride too once they’re near the endzone
Kirk had that one career year in Duval, then never came close to that again.
Marv has had the same problems with Jacoby as with Kyler(mental lapses, drops).
There’s a reason you named the guys I already named & had to reach for a small sample size for the 3rd one.He's never passed 4000 yards. You can safely say he's held everyone back.
Zay Jones more than quadrupled his yards with JB. As has Mike. Trey's yards are up too.
It sounds to me like there was possibly a route running issue with Wilson that has corrected itself with Brissett. Given the uneven play of Harrison and the story behind Wilson’s resurgence, it sounds like maybe the WR coach isn’t up to par? Also feels like Kyler made very little effort to bond and work extra with the WRs.i find it concerning that for two and a half years this staff has had Mike W on the roster, saw him everyday in practice and decided he would have the scraps in the passing offense
Drew and company should have viewed getting Mike W matched up one on one (with Trey and Marv drawing most of the attention) with the weakest member of the defensive secondary as a giant opportunity for some plays
In his press conference this week, after crediting Brissett with continually sending him film breakdowns and pointers vs. each defense, Wilson credits WR coach Drew Terrell for improving his route running and techniques. Sounded like more than just an obligatory polite nod or lip service.It sounds to me like there was possibly a route running issue with Wilson that has corrected itself with Brissett. Given the uneven play of Harrison and the story behind Wilson’s resurgence, it sounds like maybe the WR coach isn’t up to par? Also feels like Kyler made very little effort to bond and work extra with the WRs.
Probably? Especially the last couple years. He could maybe be in the Chase/Jefferson tier but he’s one or two down from there because of the QB and system.Is Hurts holding AJ Brown back?