Kyler Poll

[kerouac9]

I'm going to abstain from this poll.

I think it would be much more interesting to conduct it after this season. 100%.

Hope we do so and that the necessary amount of contrition is then exhibited.

You can do both. This is basically what every offseason is about with Kyler Murray at QB.

 

[oaken1]

I'm going to abstain from this poll.

I think it would be much more interesting to conduct it after this season. 100%.

Hope we do so and that the necessary amount of contrition is then exhibited.

Maybe before "and" after??
See if public perceptions have changed.
I'm abstaining too though. I have no interest in Kyler’s pole

 

[unseenaz]

I'm going to abstain from this poll.

I think it would be much more interesting to conduct it after this season. 100%.

Hope we do so and that the necessary amount of contrition is then exhibited.

Why after the season? We have 6 years of play to form an opinion.

 

[BritCard]

I'm going to abstain from this poll.

I think it would be much more interesting to conduct it after this season. 100%.

Hope we do so and that the necessary amount of contrition is then exhibited.

You should do it now, because we will run it again after the season to see how it's changed.

 

[Crimson Warrior]

Why after the season? We have 6 years of play to form an opinion.

Because I think this season's results will be an especially critical and influential data point for this type of analysis.

 

[Chopper0080]

Neither Geno nor Kyler are in the same tier as Dak. Kyler over Geno isn’t a hot take or anything.

Geno runs circles around Kyler.

 

[Chopper0080]

I think he is better than Dak and always have. Dak gets a boost just because he is the QB for Dallas.

He's not.

 

[BooksOrangePlanet]

Geno runs circles around Kyler.

i bet kyler has better stats this year

 

[Crimson Warrior]

You should do it now, because we will run it again after the season to see how it's changed.

Thank you for setting it up! The guys seem to find it interesting.

But I'm confident I know what effect 2025's games will have on a reasonable person's assessment so I don't need to complete it preseason. So, no thank you.

 

[PDXChris]

I need to know who the 2% that chose Kyler over Mahomes, 4% that chose Kyler over Allen, 9% that chose him over Borrow and 11% that chose him over Lamar are.

I mis-clicked on Mahomes. I am probably that 4%.

 

[PDXChris]

Geno runs circles around Kyler.

Geno is build to be a mobile QB and take hits. He will always have that over Kyler and that is BIG!

 

[HoodieBets]

Im shocked more people picked him over Penix. Give me the upside there over the known here.

 

[Chopper0080]

i bet kyler has better stats this year

One of the most underdiscussed things in the NFL is the performance of Geno Smith since he won the starting job in Seattle.

28-24 since 2021.
Two HCs.
Two OCs (both terrible)
Terrible offensive line.
Two Pro Bowls
1 playoff appearance
Over 4200 passing yards in two of his three full seasons as the starter.
Over 64% completion % all 4 seasons
Over 20 passing TDs all 3 full seasons
12 game winning drives
Over 7.3 yards per attempt every season

 

[BooksOrangePlanet]

One of the most underdiscussed things in the NFL is the performance of Geno Smith since he won the starting job in Seattle.

28-24 since 2021.
Two HCs.
Two OCs (both terrible)
Terrible offensive line.
Two Pro Bowls
1 playoff appearance
Over 4200 passing yards in two of his three full seasons as the starter.
Over 64% completion % all 4 seasons
Over 20 passing TDs all 3 full seasons
12 game winning drives
Over 7.3 yards per attempt every season

geno calmed down - game slowed down

 

[BritCard]

One of the most underdiscussed things in the NFL is the performance of Geno Smith since he won the starting job in Seattle.

28-24 since 2021.
Two HCs.
Two OCs (both terrible)
Terrible offensive line.
Two Pro Bowls
1 playoff appearance
Over 4200 passing yards in two of his three full seasons as the starter.
Over 64% completion % all 4 seasons
Over 20 passing TDs all 3 full seasons
12 game winning drives
Over 7.3 yards per attempt every season

He has worst receiving talent at the Raiders so that is going to have an effect, but he's still better than Kyler. Too many still thinking about 2014 Geno.

 

[football karma]

One of the most underdiscussed things in the NFL is the performance of Geno Smith since he won the starting job in Seattle.

28-24 since 2021.
Two HCs.
Two OCs (both terrible)
Terrible offensive line.
Two Pro Bowls
1 playoff appearance
Over 4200 passing yards in two of his three full seasons as the starter.
Over 64% completion % all 4 seasons
Over 20 passing TDs all 3 full seasons
12 game winning drives
Over 7.3 yards per attempt every season

as well as upper tier skill people around him: Tyler Lockett, DK Metcalf and JSN. Kenneth Walker / Charbonnet at RB.

 

[Stout]

One of the most underdiscussed things in the NFL is the performance of Geno Smith since he won the starting job in Seattle.

28-24 since 2021.
Two HCs.
Two OCs (both terrible)
Terrible offensive line.
Two Pro Bowls
1 playoff appearance
Over 4200 passing yards in two of his three full seasons as the starter.
Over 64% completion % all 4 seasons
Over 20 passing TDs all 3 full seasons
12 game winning drives
Over 7.3 yards per attempt every season

But, but, he didn't have perfect teams around him! You can't possibly be any good without a perfect team and perfect coaching staff around you, right? (Insert Padme meme here). Right???

 

[Chopper0080]

as well as upper tier skill people around him: Tyler Lockett, DK Metcalf and JSN. Kenneth Walker / Charbonnet at RB.

Walker has had one season over 4.1 yards per attempt. he has exceeded 1000 yards once.

Charbs has never rushed for more than 600 yards.

Geno has never had a pass catcher who had more receiving yards than McBride had last year.

Also, comparing bad offensive line vs good skill players TO good offensive line vs bad skill players is quibbling. Geno has lapped Kyler, unquestionably, in the same division and with an equally chaotic environment.

 

[WeBlitz]

Going into multiple Kyler threads, despite there already being a stickied Kyler thread, where it’s mainly just slander is so depressing. I really hope he’s finally consistent for the whole season this year.

 

[PDXChris]

Walker has had one season over 4.1 yards per attempt. he has exceeded 1000 yards once.

Charbs has never rushed for more than 600 yards.

Geno has never had a pass catcher who had more receiving yards than McBride had last year.

Also, comparing bad offensive line vs good skill players TO good offensive line vs bad skill players is quibbling. Geno has lapped Kyler, unquestionably, in the same division and with an equally chaotic environment.

The Seahawks let a top 5 under pressure QB go for a bottom 5 under pressure QB with minimal OL upgrades! Good for Geno to move on! I do not know a single Seahawks fan up here happy about that. People are already screaming for Milroe to start! They are convinced he will be the next RW since they were both 3rd rounders and they are hoping the Darold is Matt Flynn 2.0.

This is me when they try to explain how it's history repeating itself.

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[GatorAZ]

Geno runs circles around Kyler.

Nah but if you said he’s marginally better I won’t argue with it.

 

[MadCardDisease]

Based on the poll results, Kyler is sitting in that 10-15 range of QBs. Pretty much the tier where I would expect him to be heading into this season.

 

[vince56]

This is not serious is it? Flacco is currently a horrible QB. This is about their current play, not their best season

Oh we’re doing current? Why is Carson Palmer there?

 

[BritCard]

as well as upper tier skill people around him: Tyler Lockett, DK Metcalf and JSN. Kenneth Walker / Charbonnet at RB.

Has nobody watched Geno Smith throw a football recently?

 

[BritCard]

Oh we’re doing current? Why is Carson Palmer there?

Because I wanted to see fans opinions on Kyler vs Carson