I for one still think if Levi hadn't gone down, he would have been burned around the edge similarly as he was in previous years. Him being injured is worse than having him, but not by much...in the passing game.
Was he better than Batiste? Not in pass blocking very much. Run blocking yeah, I've always said that. Levi is a good run blocking tackle.
But in pass blocking he's not much better than Batiste. A couple less sacks at this point from his side? Well out of 39 sacks so far, what's a couple less? It's not like losing Levi had the effect of going from Orlando Pace in his prime to Batiste.
As for Batiste at Right tackle, as crappy as he's played, I'm not sold that he'd be adequate at right tackle. Bridges wasn't exactly doing a good job either. He was on the downside. I'd rather have him out there, but he looked as good as anyone else that was competing for that position. So his time looked about up.
I do lay blame at Rod Graves, because he is the general manager, and our pass blocking has been ignored in the draft and free agency for years. It's not just injuries, it's our talent even before or after injuries.
Now maybe we have Russ Grimm telling him not to draft people high or not pushing him to sign FA's, that he can turn any crap into gold, but aside from that, Rod Graves has not provided Grimm the talent to build a successful line.
I mean the blame lies somewhere, and it isn't 'injuries' that did it. I'm more of the mindset that the guys getting the players and ignoring certain positions, such as the OL, more or less, is to blame over the guy trying to coach crap into serviceable. I'm not sold on the scheme. I'm not sold in our response. But to start with you need to have NFL caliber OL'men, especially our tackles, and we don't.
I'm not a 'Rod Graves' basher about everything. I'll say when he makes good moves, or bad moves. The thing that sticks out and he owns it imo, is the decision whether it was FA or Draft, not to bring in quality OL, especially at the tackle positions.
I suspected that maybe Snyder was brought in so he could be a pulling guard. Otherwise the move made no sense to bring in a division rivals worst OL'men, and stats wise (while they aren't everything) one of the worst in football last year. We haven't seen much pulling, we've seen much sacking and little push in the run game from his responsibilities.
With a competent OL this team is easily playoff potential, perhaps championship potential. With this OL, we are a laughingstock. With Levi we're still a laughingstock potential OL, just like previous years. We did give up 54 sacks last year, even WITH Levi, and even WITH him finally doing better the last half the season. If he hadn't we'd probably have given up 60. He wasn't exactly doing great before his injury in preseason, even if it was meaningless preseason.
Even with Levi, I'm sure at this point of the season, he'd of given up a good number of sacks too. Sure he had a good 7 or 8 game stretch last season, but as we could see, the OL wasn't laughingstock bad the first four weeks of the season in terms of pass blocking. It was still bad, but not laughingstock. We were lucky teams weren't taking advantage, but in time they did again. Then it showed up again. We sure didn't run the ball very well.
We still gave up 54 sacks last year as a whole, and a good portion of those were Levi being burned around the corner. A major problem his whole career, and something that will probably plague him his whole career. When he comes back, guys will still burn right around him. I'm seeing the same thing without Levi as I saw with, just it's happening a little more often. But looks the same. Burned to the outside consistently, then gets in a funk overcompensates and gets burned on swim and spin moves to the inside. Just like Levi.
The signing was at a reasonable price, but I had hoped we'd switch him to RT, and if he doesn't work out there, then he's a backup with cut potential and not on a bad contract. A GM concerned with the OL wouldn't sign him and think it's settled, or even allow it to reach that point.
I've always given Graves credit where he deserves it, and lay blame on him when he doesn't. To me, the lack of focus on the OL and Kolb's contract were his worst moves.
I've always been understanding of trying to sign quality talent at cheaper prices as Graves would call it 'the patriots model', with the occasional splash we all wish would come as well. For trying to manage our cap decently, and not get ourselves in cap hell, etc. But the lack of attention on the OL is on someone's head. If not Graves, then who?
Then again also the Patriots model is to get as many draft picks through trades and compensatory picks as possible. So it's only partially the Patriots model.
Had Levi and Bridges not gone down, our OL still would have been imo #1 in sacks. It's basically what we've been with those guys. Usually #2.
Again in case anyone cares here's the top teams giving up sacks the last few years....and before Levi's 2nd half reprieve, it looked like it he was getting worse.
2010
1. Bears 56
2. Cardinals 50
3. Carolina 50
32. Giants 16
2011
1. Rams 55
2. Cardinals 54
3. Dolphins 52
32. Bills 23
2012 (8 games)
1. Cardinals 39
2. Packers 28
3. Bears 25
32. Giants 7
Alot of our sacks have been given up not just on the outside, but also our inside, by guys like Snyder, Colledge and Sendlein, etc.
Obviously our two best OL'men are Colledge and Sendlein, and Sendlein is a smart center, but overall these two guys aren't very good either. If they're your two weakest once the ball is snapped, you're line is probably good. If they're you're best, then you're screwed.
Levi, Bridges, Snyder, Batiste, Massie all suck. There's hope Massie improves, but the rest are pretty much set in stone. We're only pressed to start the rookie because none of our other players can step up. It was Brown who got injured. Had we upgraded the position, it doesn't mean whoever else was there would have gotten injured. So it's apples and oranges. Either way with or without Levi, our line would have been burned.
When Levi returns, sure he'll set the edge on run blocking, but on passing downs he'll get burned pretty regularly like he has the majority of his career. Lots of DE's had career days against Levi just like they are against Batiste. So it's beyond injuries with our line. We lost a guy who gets burned regularly, and replaced him with a guy who gets burned a tad more often than regularly.
But now it's not just our tackles, it's also our inside line play, and Graves just signed Adam Snyder this offseason.
Hopefully Massie, Potter, Kelemete work out, but overall this past 1/2 decade or more, even with Warner here, our line has been horrible at pass blocking. Just with Warner he could get rid of the ball way faster than an average QB because he was that good. He hid our deficiencies. We don't have that option now. Our pass blocking suckage, for the nth year in a row is on display.
Is it worse because of injuries? Yeah. Not by much though. Given the moves Graves did was to re-sign a LT that gets burned and contributed heavily in poor pass blocking since he came into the league, and signed Snyder who has also been a problem, I'd say yeah, with him being the GM, it's on him. Instead of 39 sacks, what would we have given up with Levi at LT and Batiste at RT...33 instead of 39? 30? Still a crappy number.
Still was going to get our QB killed. Would have gotten any QB killed. We have Koncussion Kolb. Still an obvious, glaring hole that Graves should have addressed, and given that reality we were afforded a 4-0 head start on the competition, we should have been busy trying to solidify our gains while playing with house money and brought someone in. Our situation is desperate, and we could have signed some people that were cut. Could of signed some guys after Levi went down. Could of swung a trade. Could of done other things the previous five years. The writing has been on the wall for years what speed rushers could do to us. We've been abnormally bad at it Whiz's whole tenure here. Levi or no Levi.
Helped Warner not stay on another year. Helped Manning choose another spot. Killed Kolb how many times now? Skelton. Gave Max Hall the Rosenbach treatment. Every QB here has been murdered from poor line play. How many QB's do we have to go through to figure it out. There's another one laying on the carpet. Dang, come offseason what should we do?
The #1 through #4 priority this offseason is....sign and high round draft players that can fix this, or at least give us a legitimate shot to, as nothing is certain. But Graves could focus on it for a change. Then I'll give him credit for that, like I have his other good moves.