Indiana high school softball all-state teams: Coaches pick IHSAA's top players

[ASFN Admin]

The Softball Coaches Association of Indiana announced its all-state honorees for the 2026 high school softball season.

Players are divided into Class A/2A and 3A/4A, with first, second and third teams for each class. Teams were selected through a process organized by the SCAI.

Class 4A/3A​

FIRST TEAM​

• Paige Liezert, sr., Crown Point
• Lexi Iwema, sr., Lake Central
• Maddie Such, jr., Lake Central
• Sienna Stilley, sr., Hanover Central
• Ally Compton, jr., Munster
• Logan Rumble, sr., Penn
• Taylor Danley, sr., Carroll
• Leah Shappell, sr., Leo
• Caitlyn Denny, sr., Penn
• Maeve Miltner, jr., FW Bishop Dwenger
• Brynley Erb, sr., Western
• Haley Schatko, sr., Noblesville
• Jayden Kleiner, sr., Carmel
• Grace Swedarsky, sr., Hamilton Southeastern
• Olivia Jones, so., Yorktown
• Brynn Meyer, sr., Center Grove
• Sidney Feczko, sr., Cathedral
• Lilly Heath, sr., Avon
• Elise Baker, sr., Roncalli
• Harper Moore, jr., Beech Grove
• Taylor Barrett, jr., Center Grove
• Riley Byford, sr., Jennings County
• Harper Adams, jr., Greensburg Community
• Kaitlyn Whitlock, sr., Silver Creek
• Baleigh Fish, jr., Columbus East
• Arian Day, jr., Jennings County
• Emma Bruggenschmidt, sr., Castle
• Brianna Barrix, jr., Jasper
• Lily Greenwell, sr., Castle
• Laney Scherer, jr., Gibson Southern
• Grace Archer, sr., Vincennes Lincoln

SECOND TEAM​

• Ashlyn Kita, sr., Crown Point
• Madi Wainwright, jr., Lake Central
• Jillian DeYoung, so., Hanover Central
• Tegan Tripp, sr., Lake Central
• Delilah Kincaid, jr., Valparaiso
• Madison Jones, jr., Fairfield
• Khloe Hershey, sr., Mishawaka
• Shea Crawford, so., Mishawaka
• Ava Walker, jr., Elkhart
• Kiley Weinberg, sr., South Bend Saint Joseph
• Savvanna Riall, sr., Greenfield Central
• Brooklynn Hagerty, jr., Logansport
• Kristen Wineinger, sr., Greenfield Central
• Hallie Schwieterman, jr., Jay County
• Lucy George, jr., Western
• Allison Bland, sr., Edgewood
• Maggie Krause, sr., Northview
• Delaney Jones, sr., Indian Creek
• AG Pogue, sr., Brownsburg
• Adalynn Foster, sr., Franklin Central
• Sadey Hughbanks, sr., New Palestine
• Kenzi Arnett, jr., Plainfield
• Caitlyn Fox, jr., Batesville
• Kendall Christie, sr., North Harrison
• Ava Cutter, jr., South Dearborn
• Aubrey Leugers, sr., Franklin Community
• Kenzie Zigler, jr., Terre Haute North
• Carly Potts, sr., Gibson Southern
• Alaina Allyn, sr., Mount Vernon
• Emily Parker, sr., Boonville
• Emmy Miller, sr., Floyd Central
• Ella Wilkey, sr., Southridge

THIRD TEAM​

• Scarlette Tegtman, sr., Crown Point
• Preslee Hill, sr., Lowell
• Evi Cuevas, jr., Crown Point
• Camryn Young, fr., Griffith
• Lauren Mish, jr., Iliana Christian
• Caroline Wendlinger, jr., Munster
• Peyton Grindstaff, so., Garrett
• Aubrey Helmkamp, jr., East Noble
• Rachel Humbarger, sr., Northridge
• Dellancey Jenkins, so., South Bend Riley
• Charlie Swiger, so., Penn
• Makayla Watson, sr., Westfield
• Jaycee McCarter, fr., Hamilton Southeastern
• Aubrey Fox, jr., Pendleton Heights
• Reese Newsom, jr., Noblesville
• Adrianne Cook, sr., Fishers
• Madison Bland, sr., Edgewood
• Kiley Renick, sr., Franklin Central
• Lacie Godby, sr., Cascade
• Jordyn Hazelwood, so., Cathedral
• Bennie Leffler, sr., Roncalli
• Jillian Cavanaugh, sr., Lawrenceburg
• Jaleigh Lindley, sr., Terre Haute North
• Carly Reed, sr., Bloomington South
• Lola Watkins, jr., Columbus East
• Annabelle Richter, sr., Franklin Community
• Kyleigh Walker, jr., Terre Haute North
• Maddie Rose, jr., Castle
• Brianna Canaan, jr., Evansville Memorial
• Lily Hester, jr., North Posey
• Elise Coleman, sr., Floyd Central
• Emma Fischer, jr., Heritage Hills

Class 2A/A​

FIRST TEAM​

• Madilyn Nevitt, sr., Tri-County High School
• Jordyn Botma, jr., Boone Grove High School
• Grace Luck, sr., Tri-County High School
• Cheryl Barnes, sr., Knox
• Eliana Grubbs, sr., Bremen
• Grace Swank, sr., Central Noble
• Lauren Hardy, fr., Covington Community
• Sami Leopard, so., Delphi Community
• Abie Pearson, sr., Delphi Community
• Allie Hardy, fr., Prairie Heights
• Kelsey Armes, sr., Elwood Community
• Emillia Andrews, sr., Eastern - Greentown
• Ella Barry, sr., Southmont
• Hadley West, sr., Manchester
• Jaiden Moses, sr., Indiana School for the Deaf
• Kenna Streeval, sr., Edinburgh Community
• Ashlyn Hittle, so., Triton Central
• Ryan Works, sr., Rising Sun
• Kynadee Bode, sr., Milan
• Lanee Swindell, jr., Knightstown
• Karlee Smith, sr., Clay City
• Sydney Wilson, sr., Barr-Reeve
• Faith Mitchell, sr., Clay City
• Lila Koontz, sr., Bloomfield
• Hallie Knepp, jr., Barr-Reeve
• Audrey Seiler, so., Tecumseh
• Jaylynn Hobbs, sr., Sullivan
• Addyson Phillips, jr., Wood Memorial
• Avery Long, jr., Tecumseh
• Bre Harris, jr., Tecumseh

SECOND TEAM​

• Ashlyn Hite, sr., Andrean
• Maggie Keller, jr., Winamac Community
• Hadley Donovan, sr., Hebron
• Maddy McCoy, sr., Andrean
• Lois Layer, sr., Pioneer
• Addi Gorbettl, sr., Rossville
• Autumn Paschal, sr., Rossville
• Victoria Crozier, sr., Woodlan
• Hayley Hardy, jr., Prairie Heights
• Bailey Bateman, fr., Lakeland
• Keera Grizzle, so., Clinton Prairie
• Ryleigh Myers, so., Oak Hill
• Brynlee Humphries, jr., Alexandria-Monroe
• Zoey Coppess, so., Frankton
• Bria Rensberger, sr., Rochester
• Mallory Eaglin, sr., Knightstown
• Avery Dungan, sr., Tri High
• Lily Courtney, sr., Rising Sun
• Elaina Titkemeyer, sr., Rising Sun
• McKenna Eaglin, fr., Milan
• Addilyn Rodich, fr., North Daviess
• Lucy Wirtz, sr., Barr-Reeve
• Addison Lafree, sr., Bloomfield
• Jaylee Yeadon, so., Brownstown Central
• Mariah Scott, fr., Clay City
• Braelyn Gladish, so., South Knox
• Melanie Pfeiffer, sr., Tecumseh
• Delaney Pennington, jr., South Central
• Olivia Griffith, sr., Linton-Stockton
• Layla Manship, sr., West Washington

THIRD TEAM​

• Olivia Treece, jr., Boone Grove
• Layla Winrott, sr., Jimtown
• Makayla Werner, sr., Winamac Community
• Kylee Logan, sr., Caston
• Addison Sponaugle, jr., Knox
• Molly Madsen, sr., North Judson-San Pierre
• Olivia Timm, jr., North Judson-San Pierre
• Meredith Hindbaugh, so., Whitko
• Kynee Myers, so., Rossville
• Kaitlyn Tilley, jr., Central Noble
• Mackenzea Causey, sr., Eastern Greentown
• Savanna Hall, jr., Cowan
• Kinley Webb, jr., Alexandria Monroe
• Ava Hubner, sr., Lewis Cass
• Alyxandra Smith, jr., Alexandria Monroe
• Stella Griffin, jr., Alexandria Monroe
• Kalli Davis, sr., Wabash
• Lyla Williams, sr., Tri High
• Leyla Miller, sr., Indianapolis Lutheran
• Sawyer Rogers, so., Morristown
• Aviana Ramos, sr., Winchester Community Monte Gaddis
• Hailey Elsrod, jr., Northeastern
• Ellie Stoelting, jr., Clay City
• Madelyn Knepp, sr., North Daviess
• Kenadie Garloch, sr., Salem
• Haley Huff, so., Barr-Reeve
• Josie Beavers, fr., Brownstown Central
• Ellie Allen, sr., North Knox
• Audrey Sullivan, so., Linton-Stockton
• Addison Stepro, jr., South Central
• Makenna Mills, sr., Lanesville
• Keelei Brown, so., Linton-Stockton

Follow Brian Haenchen on Twitter at @Brian_Haenchen. Get IndyStar's high school coverage sent directly to your inbox with the High School Sports newsletter.

This article originally appeared on Indianapolis Star: Indiana softball All-State teams 2026: IHSAA top players

Continue reading...