Bust of 2025

[Mulli]

I'm not accepting "Browns" as he was consensus top 10. I'll go with everything else that's been said, though. Wonder why he was considered consensus top 10?

Because Browns

 

[MadCardDisease]

He is a day 2 pick but Isaac Teslaa in the 3rd round to the Lions was a head scratcher and huge bust potential.

 

[Mulli]

He is a day 2 pick but Isaac Tesla in the 3rd round to the Lions was a head scratcher and huge bust potential.

Low energy guy? Small motor? HEyO!!!

 

[phillycard]

Mason Graham. Massively overrated.

Just three 2.5/3 sack seasons despite playing on a talented line. 9 sacks in 39 games. Played at 320 ish, now down to 295ish. Body looks sloppy to me.

Measurables are trash. 7th percentile hand size, 26th bench, 25th wingspan, 12th percentile arm length. 50th percentile 40.

These are not the shoulders of a top 5 DT.

I don't see him living up to his draft position. Would not be surprised if multiple DT's from this class are better.

You must be registered for see images attach

Agreed Brit! When he walked up to the podium I was like..."This is Mason Graham??" I literally had no idea what he looked like. Just heard his name.

 

[Mulli]

Agreed Brit! When he walked up to the podium I was like..."This is Mason Graham??" I literally had no idea what he looked like. Just heard his name.

I thought the same thing

 

[MadCardDisease]

I thought the same thing

I did the same thing when Darth Vader took his helmet off:

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[BritCard]

There's no Tyree Wilson in this years draft though. I was absolutely sure with every fibre of my being he was going to be Clerin Ferrell, and he has indeed sucked balls for a top 10 pick. Dude was pick #7 and only just scraped 50% of snaps in a depleted edge group. Dude got out snapped by another bust, K'Lavon Chaisson.

 

[oaken1]

He is a day 2 pick but Isaac Teslaa in the 3rd round to the Lions was a head scratcher and huge bust potential.

yeah,...and Teslaas stock has been falling for months

 

[BirdGangThing]

yeah,...and Teslaas stock has been falling for months

damn elon

 

[BACH]

There's no Tyree Wilson in this years draft though. I was absolutely sure with every fibre of my being he was going to be Clerin Ferrell, and he has indeed sucked balls for a top 10 pick. Dude was pick #7 and only just scraped 50% of snaps in a depleted edge group. Dude got out snapped by another bust, K'Lavon Chaisson.

Steward is that guy. But higher floor than Wilson.

 

[HairZach]

I thought the same thing

I remember when people here thought Bowers would be a bust because of the photo of him standing next to Gronk.

 

[BritCard]

Steward is that guy. But higher floor than Wilson.

He's the opposite player for me. Stewart as the physical ability and talent but not the stats.

Wilson had the stats but was terrible to watch. Stiff and slow off the snap. Just played bad teams.

 

[Shane]

He's the opposite player for me. Stewart as the physical ability and talent but not the stats.

Wilson had the stats but was terrible to watch. Stiff and slow off the snap. Just played bad teams.

Why wasn’t Shemar piling up stats then against the likes of Bowling Green, Mcneese, New Mexico State, Mississippi state and a very very mediocre USC?

 

[BritCard]

Why wasn’t Shemar piling up stats then against the likes of Bowling Green, Mcneese, New Mexico State, Mississippi state and a very very mediocre USC?

I'm thinking scheme and what he was asked to do on that defense. Because I'm looking at Nic Scourton on the other side and seeing his production drop off a cliff after moving to A&M.

I'm not saying Stewart is going to be great, but I think he'll be fine for where he was drafted.

 

[BACH]

He's the opposite player for me. Stewart as the physical ability and talent but not the stats.

Wilson had the stats but was terrible to watch. Stiff and slow off the snap. Just played bad teams.

Not an expert. Quoting CTM podcast that more or less did an entire hour just on him and the athletic edge without production discussion.

They evaluated him as having a higher floor. Good player. Good against the run. Just didn’t buy that he will ever have pass-rush production over the 6-8 sack range

 

[gmabel830]

Walter "Nkimdiche" Nolen.... because somebody had to do it!

 

[BullheadCardFan]

Walter "Nkimdiche" Nolen.... because somebody had to do it!

 

[Garthshort]

i think travis hunter should focus exclusively on receiving

The first time he drops a pass all the fans will say that it wouldn't have happened, if he wasn't spending so much time playing DB. And vice/versa, if he gives up a completion. He's just lucky he doesn't have to go under the microscope of this Board.

 

[BirdGangThing]

The first time he drops a pass all the fans will say that it wouldn't have happened, if he wasn't spending so much time playing DB. And vice/versa, if he gives up a completion. He's just lucky he doesn't have to go under the microscope of this Board.

i think he's a better receiver and big time receivers make more - i wouldn't play both sides unless i was getting paid double - maybe a few situational circumstances but im not doubling my risk of injury

 

[Ronin]

Why wasn’t Shemar piling up stats then against the likes of Bowling Green, Mcneese, New Mexico State, Mississippi state and a very very mediocre USC?

Cause NMSU is a real school!

 

[WisconsinCard]

Walter "Nkimdiche" Nolen.... because somebody had to do it!

2025 NFL Draft: Five Most Likely Busts in the NFC

Will the Saints be able to get the most out of Tyler Shough? Plus, the Cardinals rolled the dice on a boom-or-bust prospect.

www.si.com

 

[SunsTzu]

2025 NFL Draft: Five Most Likely Busts in the NFC

Will the Saints be able to get the most out of Tyler Shough? Plus, the Cardinals rolled the dice on a boom-or-bust prospect.

www.si.com

Nolen was so bad at A&M that the 2 seasons he was there he had more tackles, TFL and sacks than the guy picked immediately after him had in 3 years at the same school.

 

[gmabel830]

2025 NFL Draft: Five Most Likely Busts in the NFC

Will the Saints be able to get the most out of Tyler Shough? Plus, the Cardinals rolled the dice on a boom-or-bust prospect.

www.si.com

Ok, I officially retract my Nolen prediction because someone else actually did it.

 

[az jam]

Travis Hunter. Is he really elite at both WR & CB? Won't be in the NFL at Jacksonville.

 

[DVontel]

Travis Hunter. Is he really elite at both WR & CB? Won't be in the NFL at Jacksonville.

Could be. Even if he’s elite at only one, that still wouldn’t be considered nowhere near a bust.