Authoritative 2025 Starting QB Power Ranking/Tiers

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
30,062
Reaction score
45,869
Location
Colorado
This is laughable.

Herbert over a Super Bowl MVP winner, and been to the Super Bowl twice.

This love affair with Herbert is beyond gross.

Right now Mahomes is the only better QB leading a team than Hurts and even he has been outplayed by him in every game they have faced each other.

K1 no doubt is a tier 2 guy.
Not when he has been outplayed by Geno Smith over the past three seasons.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
30,062
Reaction score
45,869
Location
Colorado
This is laughable.

Herbert over a Super Bowl MVP winner, and been to the Super Bowl twice.

This love affair with Herbert is beyond gross.

Right now Mahomes is the only better QB leading a team than Hurts and even he has been outplayed by him in every game they have faced each other.

K1 no doubt is a tier 2 guy.
Don’t you argue that Purdy is mid and is being carried by a great roster? How is Hurts different?
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
91,810
Reaction score
43,575
I had a story on my FB feed that said McCarthy can throw the ball 80 yards, has the arm of Josh Allen, the touch of Mahomes, runs like Lamar, he's the next great QB. I wouldn't be stunned if he's good, in that offense it seems lots of QB's look good but I have to admit I never was high on him in college?

Harbaugh didn't really open him up until his last year. Hard to complain the last 2 years 44 TD 9 INT is damn good but in such a run heavy offense that he always saw defenses geared against the run.

he's very athletic and looks the part I think it will be interesting to watch
 

BulldogCard

Veteran
Joined
Nov 5, 2021
Posts
471
Reaction score
472
Location
AZ
Mahomes didn't have that great of stats last season, but was part of a complete, good, well coached team, and maybe some other factors we won't talk about. These lists are subjective, but until anyone proves otherwise kind of list. This list will change.
 
OP
OP
kerouac9

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
39,976
Reaction score
33,461
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Mahomes didn't have that great of stats last season, but was part of a complete, good, well coached team, and maybe some other factors we won't talk about. These lists are subjective, but until anyone proves otherwise kind of list. This list will change.
Wrong this list is authoritative ;)
 
Top