So Alex started against Atlanta and St. Louis? That would make him 4-5 as a starter.....I could've sworn his first start was against the Colts.
Actually it's around 60%.
2009 San Francisco 49ers "Season" thread!!
- Thread starter Linderbee
- Start date
IAWarnerFan
Warnerphile, but a Cards fan!
And Hill was .500 when yanked in favor of Smith. Your point?
Someone said Smith was 3-7 as a starter this season. which he is not.
Smith is 3-4 without any without practicing with the #1 team, during the offseason.
Comprende?
IAWarnerFan
Warnerphile, but a Cards fan!
3-3>3-4 
Hill>Smith
Hill>Smith
You must be registered for see images
Renz
An Army of One
That would make his winning percentage 43%, not the 60% that you claimed.
But feel free to continue to make stuff up if it helps you feel better about your "franchise" QB.
Renz
An Army of One
3-3>3-4
Hill>Smith
Plus, the three games that the Whiners won that Smith started (CHI, JAX, AZ) they would have won those games under Hill also. They won those games because of defense, not anything Smith did.
If Hill had started against Indy and Seattle, maybe they win those games. Even one TD drive in the second half of those games probably would have led to a SF win, but Smith didn't do squat in the second half of either game.
Of course Ronin and Singletary would go out of their way to make excuses for Smith and blame Gore, the WR's, Davis etc., but the fact is that Smith didn't get it done and hasn't over his career.
If Hill had been the starter all season, SF is probably 7-6 or 8-5 right now. I hope SF signs Smith to a looong extension this offseason.
maybe as a backup.3-3>3-4
Hill>Smith
Ditto.
Because Everybody in SF knows Alex isn't the answer right?
Renz
An Army of One
That was an opinion. Anybody with half a brain knows that using the word "everybody" is merely an intentional exaggeration for effect.
It isn't the same as claiming that Smith has a 60% winning percentage when two post earlier you gave evidence that it was 43%. That's just, well, funny!
IAWarnerFan
Warnerphile, but a Cards fan!
Hill is a better leader and a winner. What does Smith actually bring to the table other than more arm strength?
Really? When was the last time he won a meaningful game? It wasn't this season...
Maybe You and Renz should watch a 49er game....
IAWarnerFan
Warnerphile, but a Cards fan!
What's his career record as a starter?
Yeah, kinda missed the MNF game. Unfortunately so did the Cardinals offense.Maybe You and Renz should watch a 49er game....
It's Irrelevant....most of his wins where when the season was already over.
He couldn't move the offense at all.(this season)
http://twitter.com/SHAUNPHILLIPS95
oh man, Jimmy Raye is going to have to come up with more than 1 run play against the Eagles.
It worked against the Cards, but it won't work against the Eagles.
He has the Rams and Lions coming up.
Bump for gore stats.
Renz
An Army of One
Are you talking about Hill or Smith? The next meaningful game that Smith wins will be his first.
Enjoy continued irrelevance, Whiner fans. Hopefully, that extension for Smith will come soon after the end of your season, meaning now.
[/quote]
Hill.
Whiner fans huh....wow, how original.
I think you should worry about your own bust of a quarterback.The next meaningful game that Smith wins will be his first.
Hopefully, that extension for Smith will come soon after the end of your season, meaning now.
Renz
An Army of One
Whiner fans huh....wow, how original.
For all those clever SF fans who constantly refer to the Cardinals as the 'Tards'. That one was for you!
Also, Whiner players and coaches you are going to need this for the playoffs. Again.
You must be registered for see images
Beaver
Maximum Effort
Don't worry, there is always 2014.
Ronin, you rule.
Just a little bit.
