Viral QB photo of eight legends sparks fiery debate among NFL fans

[ASFN Admin]

There is no greater barbershop debate than the one deciding the greatest of all time.

Who was the greatest receiver of all time—Jerry Rice or Randy Moss? Who is the greatest basketball player of all time—Michael Jordan or LeBron James? Who is the greatest baseball player of all time—Babe Ruth or Willie Mays? Who is the greatest quarterback of all time—Tom Brady or Joe Montana?

The latter was put to the test in a recent post from an X user on Wednesday. A photograph of eight legendary quarterbacks was posted, and the post asked people to pick the worst quarterback out of the group. The players in the photo include Brady, Montana, Peyton Manning, Patrick Mahomes, Drew Brees, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers and Dan Marino.

Who's the worst QB in this photo? pic.twitter.com/Dgtx6j37XL

— Chad (@braves2430) July 1, 2026

Brady is probably the safest in the photo considering he is widely regarded as the greatest quarterback of all time. It's hard to beat seven Super Bowl rings, with championships with two different franchises.

Marino is the only quarterback pictured without a Super Bowl ring, but from strictly a passing perspective, you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone who did it better than the former Miami Dolphin. Arguments can be made for and against every quarterback in the photo.

Here's how some fans responded to the question on social media:

Ben

— Wisconsin Family (@Wisconsin_fam) July 1, 2026

Rogers

— ✭ ✭ THE LuLuBama_Cowboys✭ ✭ ✭ (@Lulu_cowboys) July 1, 2026

Everyone saying Brees should never be allowed to watch football ever again. pic.twitter.com/N8XhJJiiNt

— Kannon (@Kannon_Fire) July 1, 2026

Probably one of these guys pic.twitter.com/dGbBXdrRBs

— ClevelandCollector (@Chuckmanintexas) July 2, 2026

Gotta be Montana. Look how old he is. No way he’s good lol

— Cashews (@BostonCashews5) July 1, 2026

I'm going with Brees. Some might say Big Ben. I don't think anyone else is even a viable answer, unless you're only looking at Super Bowls (which is very flawed if that's the case).

— Mike Huesmann (@HuesmannCFB) July 1, 2026

Ben

— Yashabru Fabe (@KingGonZilla38) July 2, 2026

Brees or Ben flip a coin.

— Leslie Renfroe (@LRenfroe79264) July 2, 2026

It's crazy to say, but I think you gotta go Ben.

Or maybe Marino with zero SuperBowls.

— Chewie (@406Northlane) July 1, 2026

The craziest thing about Brady is that all of his measureables are terrible. On paper, youd never take him over anyone else. He's also the guy that makes you regret that decision every time. Anyway, it's Ben.

— Bret (@StubbyNarwhal) July 2, 2026

Follow Patriots Wire on Twitter and Facebook.

This article originally appeared on Patriots Wire: Viral QB photo of eight legends sparks fiery debate among NFL fans

Continue reading...