Is Carson Palmer a HOF QB?

[Cbus cardsfan]

KW took 2 different teams to the Super Bowl, won 1, and is a career 93.7 QB rating, which is 10th all time. His numbers are comparable to Jim Kelly who only played in 1 more SB than KW and never won. He also has much better numbers than Aikman and Aikman is in. KW absolutely gets in.

I like KW but you have to look at the bad with the good. He basically built his career on 5 good years, 3 with Rams and 2 with the Cards. He only started 16 games 3 times in his entire career, yet people ding CP for his durability. He only threw for more than 4000 yards 3 times and threw 128 INT's to go along with his fumbles.

 

[kerouac9]

Is Drew Brees a hall of fame QB?

Yes. No doubt. First-ballot. He was a top 3 QB in the league for a five-plus year stretch and won a Super Bowl--and I think an NFL MVP.

That gets you in.

Edit: no MVP, but a first-team all-pro and NINE Pro Bowl appearances.