- Joined
- May 8, 2002
- Posts
- 1,129,517
- Reaction score
- 59
The Green Bay Packers traded wide receiver Dontayvion Wicks to the Philadelphia Eagles on Friday in exchange for a 2026 fifth-round pick and a 2027 sixth-round pick, per ESPN's Adam Schefter, as Green Bay continues to reshape the roster.
This looks like a win-win-win trade, benefitting the Packers, Wicks and the Eagles.
Firstly, from Green Bay's side, the construction of their wide receiver room really didn’t make sense for 2026 or 2027.
It was set up to be too crowded in 2026, even after losing Romeo Doubs in free agency. The Packers had six receivers who were near locks to make the team if they were on the roster in Christian Watson, Matthew Golden, Jayden Reed, Dontayvion Wicks, Savion Williams and Skyy Moore.
They could not realistically take a receiver in the upcoming draft. If they selected one on Day 2, they would be buried on the depth chart, and if they took one on Day 3, they would be facing a battle just to make the team, or lock Brian Gutekunst into keeping seven no matter what.
That was not ideal, as Green Bay ideally needed to draft someone this year, because in 2027, they have the opposite problem in that the depth chart looks pretty bare as of right now, with only Golden and Williams under contract.
Watson getting a contract extension seems like a given, but that would still only make three. The Packers were in an untenable situation where too many contracts at the same position were going to expire at the same time, and they needed to reset the clock.
In terms of the hierarchy, Golden deserved and needed to be a definite starter entering Year 2. That would probably have happened anyway, but now the path is clearer and is really taken out of the hands of the coaching staff, who can tend to stick with what they know and trust.
If the Packers wanted to let Savion Williams be a contributor in any real way in his second season after spending a third-round pick on him, he could not be stuck as WR5 on the depth chart, which he probably would have been if Wicks was still on the team.
The case against the trade is that it obviously depletes the depth at receiver this year, when Green Bay is expecting to compete for a championship.
But their depth is still solid, with Williams likely being first off the bench not a bad place to start. Given how much the Packers deployed two tight end sets last year, there will be a lot of times when one of Golden or Reed is not even on the field.
Skyy Moore and Bo Melton are ideal backend depth as fifth and sixth options even if Green Bay ends up not drafting anyone this month, and they probably will at some point.
Closing the book on Wicks’ career as a Packer, his selection was an absolute hit. They drafted him in the fifth round and in return got over 1,500 quality snaps, a fifth-round pick in 2026 and a sixth in 2027.
The Packers were highly unlikely to re-sign him, and given they are set up to spend next offseason, they may not have got a compensatory pick if he walked in free agency in a year. This was their last chance to get something.
Getting two lower picks rather than one higher pick makes sense for the Packers, as they simply needed more at bats after their draft resources were depleted in the Micah Parsons trade.
NFL general managers are always balancing the short and long term. This is a deal Gutekunst had a responsibility to make once it was on the table, for the long term health of Green Bay’s roster.
Reed is now the only Packers receiver in a true contract year, with Watson a priority re-sign, and he could still earn an extension himself. His underlying numbers in 2024 were fantastic, and undermined by his drops, which were not an issue as a rookie.
He was injured for most of 2025 but is still a very good player. All options are likely still on the table with him. For this year, a top three of Watson, Golden and Reed is something Green Bay has to be pretty happy with.
The move benefits Wicks, who is reportedly signing a one-year extension worth $12.5 million with the Eagles. He gets a big pay raise, security beyond this season and the opportunity to increase his value further.
Matt LaFleur brought up unprompted at the Annual League Meetings that some players were unhappy with their roles in 2025. Perhaps Wicks was one of them. He should see the field plenty in Philly, especially if A.J. Brown gets moved after June 1.
The Eagles are getting a good receiver who is worthy of being a No. 2 or No. 3 option in any offense. They have taken shots on players like this in the past with mixed success, but they could look smart for acquiring Wicks down the line.
This article originally appeared on Packers Wire: Dontayvion Wicks trade from Packers to Eagles is a win for all parties
Continue reading...
This looks like a win-win-win trade, benefitting the Packers, Wicks and the Eagles.
Firstly, from Green Bay's side, the construction of their wide receiver room really didn’t make sense for 2026 or 2027.
It was set up to be too crowded in 2026, even after losing Romeo Doubs in free agency. The Packers had six receivers who were near locks to make the team if they were on the roster in Christian Watson, Matthew Golden, Jayden Reed, Dontayvion Wicks, Savion Williams and Skyy Moore.
They could not realistically take a receiver in the upcoming draft. If they selected one on Day 2, they would be buried on the depth chart, and if they took one on Day 3, they would be facing a battle just to make the team, or lock Brian Gutekunst into keeping seven no matter what.
That was not ideal, as Green Bay ideally needed to draft someone this year, because in 2027, they have the opposite problem in that the depth chart looks pretty bare as of right now, with only Golden and Williams under contract.
Watson getting a contract extension seems like a given, but that would still only make three. The Packers were in an untenable situation where too many contracts at the same position were going to expire at the same time, and they needed to reset the clock.
In terms of the hierarchy, Golden deserved and needed to be a definite starter entering Year 2. That would probably have happened anyway, but now the path is clearer and is really taken out of the hands of the coaching staff, who can tend to stick with what they know and trust.
If the Packers wanted to let Savion Williams be a contributor in any real way in his second season after spending a third-round pick on him, he could not be stuck as WR5 on the depth chart, which he probably would have been if Wicks was still on the team.
The case against the trade is that it obviously depletes the depth at receiver this year, when Green Bay is expecting to compete for a championship.
But their depth is still solid, with Williams likely being first off the bench not a bad place to start. Given how much the Packers deployed two tight end sets last year, there will be a lot of times when one of Golden or Reed is not even on the field.
Skyy Moore and Bo Melton are ideal backend depth as fifth and sixth options even if Green Bay ends up not drafting anyone this month, and they probably will at some point.
Closing the book on Wicks’ career as a Packer, his selection was an absolute hit. They drafted him in the fifth round and in return got over 1,500 quality snaps, a fifth-round pick in 2026 and a sixth in 2027.
The Packers were highly unlikely to re-sign him, and given they are set up to spend next offseason, they may not have got a compensatory pick if he walked in free agency in a year. This was their last chance to get something.
Getting two lower picks rather than one higher pick makes sense for the Packers, as they simply needed more at bats after their draft resources were depleted in the Micah Parsons trade.
NFL general managers are always balancing the short and long term. This is a deal Gutekunst had a responsibility to make once it was on the table, for the long term health of Green Bay’s roster.
Reed is now the only Packers receiver in a true contract year, with Watson a priority re-sign, and he could still earn an extension himself. His underlying numbers in 2024 were fantastic, and undermined by his drops, which were not an issue as a rookie.
He was injured for most of 2025 but is still a very good player. All options are likely still on the table with him. For this year, a top three of Watson, Golden and Reed is something Green Bay has to be pretty happy with.
The move benefits Wicks, who is reportedly signing a one-year extension worth $12.5 million with the Eagles. He gets a big pay raise, security beyond this season and the opportunity to increase his value further.
Matt LaFleur brought up unprompted at the Annual League Meetings that some players were unhappy with their roles in 2025. Perhaps Wicks was one of them. He should see the field plenty in Philly, especially if A.J. Brown gets moved after June 1.
The Eagles are getting a good receiver who is worthy of being a No. 2 or No. 3 option in any offense. They have taken shots on players like this in the past with mixed success, but they could look smart for acquiring Wicks down the line.
This article originally appeared on Packers Wire: Dontayvion Wicks trade from Packers to Eagles is a win for all parties
Continue reading...
