- Joined
- May 8, 2002
- Posts
- 1,252,898
- Reaction score
- 59
You must be registered for see images attach
'Stop using bits and pieces players': R. Ashwin drops truth bomb on Gautam Gambhir's team selection strategy originally appeared on Cricket News. Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
- R Ashwin criticises Gautam Gambhir's reliance on 'bits and pieces' cricketers.
- India lost ODI series 2-1 to England to cap off a dismal UK tour.
- Ex-spinner wants a fixed 17-18 player pool for the next 14 months.
R Ashwin fires warning shot over India's ODI blueprint under Gautam Gambhir
Former India off-spinner Ravichandran Ashwin has called on head coach Gautam Gambhir to move away from filling the squad with makeshift all-rounders, as he believes the approach is a genuine concern heading into preparations for next year's ODI World Cup.
India's setup looked far from the well-oiled machine expected of a side chasing 50-over World Cup glory, even with senior names like Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma and Jasprit Bumrah back in the fold. That much was evident as the team slipped to a 2-1 series defeat against England.
Ashwin compared Gambhir's current methods and the framework his predecessor Rahul Dravid had built, arguing that leaning on part-time, bits-and-pieces cricketers represents a real structural flaw.
Central to Ashwin's concerns is the unresolved question of who fills in for Hardik Pandya. The seam-bowling all-rounder continues to battle fitness troubles, and there's still no clarity on whether he'll be match-ready by the time the World Cup arrives.
MORE: Sooryavanshi proves doubters wrong: Historic half-century vs ZIM shows he is ready for international cricket
Nitish Kumar Reddy and Shivam Dube have both emerged as possible replacements, though Reddy himself has dealt with a string of injuries recently. According to Ashwin, India can't keep papering over this faultline with stopgap all-rounders and instead needs a definitive answer to the problem.
"If Hardik is not there, it's Nitish Kumar Reddy and then Shivam Dube. There is no point in harping about players that are not ready to play in your combination. If they are injured, they are injured. That's par for the course in any sport," he said in an interview with Cricinfo.
Ashwin pointed to how differently the 2023 World Cup campaign was handled once Hardik went down injured. Rather than scrambling to search for a sixth bowling option or force a replacement into the same role, the team under Dravid simply adapted, switching to a five-bowler combination instead.
"Look at the 2023 World Cup, which just fizzled out because Hardik wasn't part of the combination," he said.
"But the moment it fizzled out, they were not searching, and they did not try to play the sixth bowler. They skinned the cat differently and went with five bowlers."
MORE: 'I'm liking the vibe here' - Vaibhav Sooryavanshi on scoring runs at Harare after maiden international 50
Ashwin went further and suggested the current management's fascination with flexible role-players may even explain India's recent struggles in Test cricket, a format he believes demands specialists rather than utility players.
"The players and the ethos in the dressing room are what will win you the World Cup. These bits and pieces have been a fascination for this management," he said.
Ashwin's blueprint for the next 14 months ahead of 2027 World Cup
Looking ahead, Ashwin proposed a clear roadmap, urging the team management to lock in a core group of 17 to 18 players and commit to them fully through the build-up to the World Cup, testing different combinations along the way rather than chopping and changing personnel.
"There needs to be clarity before any discussions about personnel. Go to 17/18 players and tell them that we are going to pick the squad from that pool and they play the next 14 months, whoever that be," he suggested.
"It has to have two keepers, three spinners and five pacers. Rotate the players in this pool with the vision of putting the best 11, come the first day of the World Cup. As of now, it's lacking a lot of clarity."
MORE: Sooryavanshi, remember the name: Fans elated as India's 'Boss Baby' hits historic 50 vs ZIM
You must be registered for see images attach
Why Ashwin's concerns deserve serious attention
Ashwin's argument lands because it's rooted in something India has actually seen work before. The 2023 World Cup run wasn't built on flashy reinvention; it came from a settled squad that knew its roles well enough to absorb a genuine crisis without falling apart.
Contrast that with the current setup, where the team still hasn't settled on a reliable all-rounder sixteen months out from the tournament, and the concern feels justified rather than reactionary.
MORE: Sachin Tendulkar vs Vaibhav Sooryavanshi after first five international innings: Comparing stats of India's youngest debutants
Bits-and-pieces cricketers have their place in T20 cricket, where matches are short and roles can blur, but 50-over cricket punishes a lack of specialisation far more harshly, as does Test cricket, which Ashwin rightly links to India's recent red-ball troubles.
Committing to a settled pool of players isn't about resisting change; it's about giving combinations time to actually develop chemistry and trust.
With little over a year left before the World Cup, India doesn't have the luxury of experimenting indefinitely, and Ashwin's call for clarity now, rather than closer to the tournament, is hard to argue with.
For all the latest cricket news, opinion, and commentary and to share your voice, head to our Facebook, Instagram, and X (Twitter) pages.
Continue reading...
