What's missing in this whole exchange is that we essentially agree on this point.
You mean you were essentially aligned?
What's missing in this whole exchange is that we essentially agree on this point.
JJ deserves blame for drafting Jalen Smith over Haliburton and others. Trading a first rd pick for Landry Shamet and not trading for Eric Gordon in 2022. I don’t place blame on him for new owner syndrome moves. I think some of the chemistry issues are on Monty.
He also should have seen the writing on the wall with Ayton and made a sign and trade deal with Indy while he still had value.
I think both Jones and Monty's heads swelled up bigger than the Grand Canyon after that 2-1/2 year run. I remember all of the interviews with both after the Dallas loss and neither would admit to any shortcomings.Yeah… I can’t give him full blame for the new owner syndrome trades, but man, he got totally taken to the cleaners on both trades, especially with all the pick swaps. He’s got to get dinged a little for those, at the very least.
Bigger issue I had after the draft pick disasters you mentioned is the whole the chemistry stuff. If a guy like Crowder wasn’t going to play, his ass should have been dealt AND we should have made moves over the summer prior to that season to compensate for the loss to come.
If anyone remembers, after the 2022 playoff humiliation, that offseason, JJ went out and signed an absolutely pathetic crop of Jock Landales and Stef Curry’s cousin, while knowing Crowder was going to be a lost cause. He also should have seen the writing on the wall with Ayton and made a sign and trade deal with Indy while he still had value.
Getting Turner for Ayton in retrospect would have been a great move. It would be fascinating to know how the last couple of years would have gone with a guy like Turner in the middle instead of Nurk/other bad. Turner is also a legit 3 point weapon, so I could see our offense being even more efficient with him at the 5.And Monty reportedly begged him to do that.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
I think matching Ayton's deal pushed Monty over the edge and he drew the line in the sand with Crowder as retaliation. He obviously couldn't do that with Ayton given the money involved as well as the Sarver, UofA, and #1 pick connections. Maybe I'm wrong but I think Monty basically gave up then. He wasn't being supported by the front office anymore and it was abundantly clear at that point.
I could definitely see this being the case.And Monty reportedly begged him to do that.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
I think matching Ayton's deal pushed Monty over the edge and he drew the line in the sand with Crowder as retaliation. He obviously couldn't do that with Ayton given the money involved as well as the Sarver, UofA, and #1 pick connections. Maybe I'm wrong but I think Monty basically gave up then. He wasn't being supported by the front office anymore and it was abundantly clear at that point.
I agree with this. I blame all those chemistry/communication issues we had a couple years ago on Monty but there's a lot that falls on JJ's shoulders. Drafting Jalen, not drafting Haliburton, giving up on Jalen so quickly, not stepping in when it was clear that Monty wasn't "getting along" with a couple of key players and a handful of questionable player decisions along the way. I think he's done a decent job as GM, sometimes under trying circumstances, but his unwillingness to value the draft is a major drawback AFAIC.JJ deserves blame for drafting Jalen Smith over Haliburton and others. Trading a first rd pick for Landry Shamet and not trading for Eric Gordon in 2022. I don’t place blame on him for new owner syndrome moves. I think some of the chemistry issues are on Monty.
I don't believe anyone here thinks Ishbia is free of blame. He is the owner and the one constant that isn't changing. Unlike Sarver, he's not in it for the money so the odds of him stepping away entirely are virtually nil. We can harp over how much of a problem Ish is repeatedly or we can hope for someone in his inner circle to right the ship. I'm in the latter group.
I'm not a Cardinals fan but I imagine it's not too different there. You all recognize the shortcomings of the Bidwill's and hope for the best in spite of their presence.
Agreed but, by far, most of our really bad draft decisions were under the McD/Sarver regime.It's fair to say the reason we are in this position is a result our draft decisions. Had we drafted better not only would we have been better, but we also wouldn't have been so desperate for the KD and Beal trades.
Everyone who supported drafting the players we did, or trading our future pics should be replaced.
It's fair to say the reason we are in this position is a result our draft decisions. Had we drafted better not only would we have been better, but we also wouldn't have been so desperate for the KD and Beal trades.
Everyone who supported drafting the players we did, or trading our future pics should be replaced.
Certainly, Ishbia is going to bear the burden of criticism for any decisions going forward. Blaming his handpicked lackey/GM isn't going to fly if the ship doesn't get righted and soon.There is only one person to look at now, the Suns owner.
Everyone else has been moved to another position or in the process of being replaced.
I'm not sure there is a way to "right the ship", at least not one that most fans would appreciate. I don't see a move or moves that would give us hope for the future and still make our current situation more palatable.Certainly, Ishbia is going to bear the burden of criticism for any decisions going forward. Blaming his handpicked lackey/GM isn't going to fly if the ship doesn't get righted and soon.
Very likely, you are correct. I fully expect a clown show. But hoping for a miracle out of left field, I suppose. Maybe they somehow stumble on the next Giannis or Jokic with a late first rounder, or they con someone in a Durant trade the same way they were conned. I dunno...I'm not sure there is a way to "right the ship", at least not one that most fans would appreciate. I don't see a move or moves that would give us hope for the future and still make our current situation more palatable.
Certainly, Ishbia is going to bear the burden of criticism for any decisions going forward. Blaming his handpicked lackey/GM isn't going to fly if the ship doesn't get righted and soon.
I'm not sure there is a way to "right the ship", at least not one that most fans would appreciate. I don't see a move or moves that would give us hope for the future and still make our current situation more palatable.
Getting Turner for Ayton in retrospect would have been a great move. It would be fascinating to know how the last couple of years would have gone with a guy like Turner in the middle instead of Nurk/other bad. Turner is also a legit 3 point weapon, so I could see our offense being even more efficient with him at the 5.
Agreed but, by far, most of our really bad draft decisions were under the McD/Sarver regime.