Most Contentious QB Discussion?

[TJ]

I've posted on here for most, if not all of the contentious QB battles, where fans sided with one QB and spit puke and vitriol towards the other side. Seems like the same dynamic is happening here with Murray v. Rosen.


Simple poll - which Cardinals QB debate was the most contentious; the one that got your blood boiling the most?

 

[Chris_Sanders]

Oh man Leinart vs Warner was rough

 

[jf-08]

How about Plummer vs Kent Graham?

 

[HoodieBets]

Max Hall vs John Skelton got all my moxies going.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[NJCardFan]

Actually, there wasn't a more contentious QB discussion than Hart vs Lomax.

 

[TJ]

Actually, there wasn't a more contentious QB discussion than Hart vs Lomax.

Don’t think ASFN is that old, though

 

[blindseyed]

How about Plummer vs Kent Graham?

Oh man THAT was a pretty good one too

 

[PACardsFan]

I recall a 2007 game in Baltimore. The Raven embarrassed Leinart in the 1st half & we were down big. Wiz inserted Warner after the half & Warner lit up a very good Ravens D by throwing for almost 300 yards in a half. Bolden was an absolute beast too. Rackets missed a chip shot FG, then Stovers kicked a 53 yarder (longest of his career) on the last play of the game. Kick was set up by a bs roughing penalty on AW, when he put a legal, but monster hit on Heap.

When I got home, I started a thread saying that Warner was the best QB on our roster. I was harassed nonstop. Oh well.

 

[Solar7]

I don't remember Leinart vs. Warner being this bad, which is interesting, because I had much man-love for Leinart.

Edit: To the point that at Leinart's Super Bowl party I practically cold shouldered Kurt and spent one too many minutes gushing to Leinart about how he was going to take us to the Super Bowl... oops on that one.

 

[TRW]

Some of the 3rd string QB drama was pretty fun through the years.

 

[oaken1]

Leinart v Warner was at least a debate about what they did in the nfl

 

[NJCardFan]

I recall a 2007 game in Baltimore. The Raven embarrassed Leinart in the 1st half & we were down big. Wiz inserted Warner after the half & Warner lit up a very good Ravens D by throwing for almost 300 yards in a half. Bolden was an absolute beast too. Rackets missed a chip shot FG, then Stovers kicked a 53 yarder (longest of his career) on the last play of the game. Kick was set up by a bs roughing penalty on AW, when he put a legal, but monster hit on Heap.

When I got home, I started a thread saying that Warner was the best QB on our roster. I was harassed nonstop. Oh well.

Was that the game where we could have challenged a play and it would have been overturned but we didn't have a timeout?

 

[TJ]

Oh man Leinart vs Warner was rough

That was my vote. I thought this board was going to go “under maintenance” for the entire offseason. That was awful and I can only imagine what it was like for you moderators.

Also I’m surprised Kolb/Skelton is getting no love. That’s was pretty brutal too

 

[BW52]

I liked Warner but I always felt Leinart didn`t get a real extended chance with the Cards.Only 17 starts in 4 years .and 16 in in first 2 years 7-10 as Cards starting QB.Glad Warner was around but dumping Leinart was premature and foolish.

 

[Dr. Jones]

I recall a 2007 game in Baltimore. The Raven embarrassed Leinart in the 1st half & we were down big. Wiz inserted Warner after the half & Warner lit up a very good Ravens D by throwing for almost 300 yards in a half. Bolden was an absolute beast too. Rackets missed a chip shot FG, then Stovers kicked a 53 yarder (longest of his career) on the last play of the game. Kick was set up by a bs roughing penalty on AW, when he put a legal, but monster hit on Heap.

When I got home, I started a thread saying that Warner was the best QB on our roster. I was harassed nonstop. Oh well.

I was there with you! hahaha

Adub got that horrible PI call on todd Heap costing us the win.

No matter what happens here with Rosen v. Murray ------ Warner v. Leinart was worse IMO.

Also, surprised that Boldin v. Fitz wasn't able to be voted on.

 

[RugbyMuffin]

What! WHAAAAAAAT!!!!!

No. Nope. Notta.

Yes, Warner/Leinart was a great debate.

But, the argument of comparing the suck-a-tude of Kolb vs. Skelton was for almost 2 YEARS!

Kolb's injury prone-ness just elongated that till it lasted, in what felt like forever.

I cannot believe I am the only one to vote on that.

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[RugbyMuffin]

I liked Warner but I always felt Leinart didn`t get a real extended chance with the Cards.Only 17 starts in 4 years .and 16 in in first 2 years 7-10 as Cards starting QB.Glad Warner was around but dumping Leinart was premature and foolish.

Proved to be the right move, Leinart never went on to do much after that and was given ample opportunity.

I was Pro-Leinart, btw.

When I got home, I started a thread saying that Warner was the best QB on our roster. I was harassed nonstop. Oh well.

Yup. Probably by me.

 

[BW52]

What! WHAAAAAAAT!!!!!

No. Nope. Notta.

Yes, Warner/Leinart was a great debate.

But, the argument of comparing the suck-a-tude of Kolb vs. Skelton was for almost 2 YEARS!

Kolb's injury prone-ness just elongated that till it lasted, in what felt like forever.

I cannot believe I am the only one to vote on that.

You must be registered for see images attach

I think most fans blank the Kolb mini-era.Poor guy got head scrambled so often he reired before 30 I do believe.

 

[TJ]

I think most fans blank the Kolb mini-era.Poor guy got head scrambled so often he reired before 30 I do believe.

Yeah. I read somewhere that he gets dizzy when he looks at bright lights and has to wear sunglasses indoors.

 

[TheCardFan]

Glad Warner was around but dumping Leinart was premature and foolish.

Drafting Leinart was one of my favorite all time Cardinal draft memories. I felt like we stole him at the time.

However, dumping him wasn't premature or foolish as the rest of his career proved.

Hopefully, Rosen isn't Leinart 2.0

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[MrYeahBut]

Blake vs Jake... lol

What a bummer the poll wasn't public...

https://www.arizonasportsfans.com/forum/threads/is-blake-an-upgrade-over-plummer.6993/

 

[ajcardfan]

I just want to say...

Josh McCown v Shaun King was a doozy.

And, that Shane Boyd craziness was off the hook.

 

[NJCardFan]

I liked Warner but I always felt Leinart didn`t get a real extended chance with the Cards.Only 17 starts in 4 years .and 16 in in first 2 years 7-10 as Cards starting QB.Glad Warner was around but dumping Leinart was premature and foolish.

Being made of glass didn't help. He got hurt in 2007 and KW showed he was the right choice. He did have a decent game against Tennessee in 2009 thought.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Delmar M Lewis]

Actually, there wasn't a more contentious QB discussion than Hart vs Lomax.

So true I just wonder if Lomax would have been a really good QB if not for his bad hip I remember he had a few really good years anyway

 

[TheCardFan]

Blake vs Jake... lol

What a bummer the poll wasn't public...

https://www.arizonasportsfans.com/forum/threads/is-blake-an-upgrade-over-plummer.6993/

Can you post Warner vs Leinart thread?