#BIDWILLOUT

Hoop Head

ASFN IDOL
Joined
Feb 4, 2005
Posts
25,234
Reaction score
22,271
Pick'em
#15 · 40 pts
Location
Your Head, Rent Free
Kinda the inherent problem is Bidwill will likely act worse as pressure mounts. Thats how his personality works. So buckle up for continued bad times. But that’ll end up forcing the leagues hand eventually

I never understood the idea that the league will act. Why would the league care if a team is bad? League rules are being followed, players and execs are paid, and other teams can chalk up AZ as an easy W. Being incompetent isn't a punishable offense.

I saw this happen with the Suns for 20 years under Sarver. The league office can't force a team to be good.
 

Gandhi

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Feb 17, 2007
Posts
2,971
Reaction score
5,177
Location
Denmark
I never understood the idea that the league will act. Why would the league care if a team is bad? League rules are being followed, players and execs are paid, and other teams can chalk up AZ as an easy W. Being incompetent isn't a punishable offense.
No, it’s not punishable. It’s because of what bad publicity could mean for the other owners.

You – and many others – are right in that it doesn’t hit the other owners financially that Cardinals is a joke on the field, but there are other ways a horribly run organization can have an effect. Now, I think the reality is that the repercussions would be bigger if it was a strong team-brand like the Cowboys, Patriots or Steelers than the irrelevant Cardinals, but it could still have an effect.

The NFL brands itself on parity. One of the main reasons – maybe the main reason – that NFL is so popular is the illusion that every year everyone has an equal chance to win it all or at least go from bad to acceptable. That’s the premium brand they sell, and that’s what TV and sponsors pay millions for. If it becomes a big story that one team owner doesn’t do enough financially to strengthen that league-wide brand and create a toxic working environment for staff and players, that could make the biggest investors (TV and sponsors) question the parity-principle. No sponsor wants to be associated with a toxic organization. Think about a major sponsor like State Farm who is directly associated with the Cardinals and get their name and brand included with the Cardinals multiple times each day. Do you think they want to be known as the company that pays millions and millions to help a bad owner run a bad organization? Or what about a TV station that week after week sends big, expensive productions to show a non-competitive team in a stadium full of away fans? It ruins “The Shield”-brand – NFL’s integrity, so to speak. The well-known motto “Protect the Shield” is exactly about that – protecting the management side of the NFL as a business.

And you have to see the fan “revolt” in connection with the multiple years of horrible NFLPA surveys related to Bidwill. Together it paints a picture of an incompetent owner who does not do his job in reference to helping promote the NFL brand. No, the league probably won’t intervene, but if TV and sponsors start to ask questions, it could be very uncomfortable for Bidwill since in that case it could also directly cost the other team owners money through multimillion external investments.
 

gimpy

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Posts
4,077
Reaction score
4,044
Location
Flagstaff, Az
I don't think he will sell. I don't think the NFL will make him sell. :cry:

What I'm hoping will happen is that he realizes how upset the fan base is and tries to rectify it somewhat. Hopefully, by stepping back from being the president, or whatever title he calls it, and puts somebody knowledgeable into the position, aaannd, give them free reign to do what's needed to make this a decent, competitive and above average successful team. :rockon:
My thoughts and hopes, only.
 

Brian in Mesa

Advocatus Diaboli
Super Moderator
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
82,600
Reaction score
38,933
Pick'em
#6 · 330 pts
Location
Killjoy Central
I don't think he will sell. I don't think the NFL will make him sell. :cry:

What I'm hoping will happen is that he realizes how upset the fan base is and tries to rectify it somewhat. Hopefully, by stepping back from being the president, or whatever title he calls it, and puts somebody knowledgeable into the position, aaannd, give them free reign to do what's needed to make this a decent, competitive and above average successful team. :rockon:
My thoughts and hopes, only.
Many of us have been saying this same thing for almost 40 years now. Step back, hire someone who knows football, you still retain ownership, and you end up looking wise when things go well or better than expected. If things don't go well, you change out the person who knows football and move on.
 

Cardinal88

All Star
Joined
Apr 28, 2019
Posts
763
Reaction score
1,386
Location
Phoenix
Many of us have been saying this same thing for almost 40 years now. Step back, hire someone who knows football, you still retain ownership, and you end up looking wise when things go well or better than expected. If things don't go well, you change out the person who knows football and move on.
I doubt this will ever happen. You hear the Bidwills are cheap but they are required to spend a certain amount for salaries. I believe where he is cheap is he never hires top end coaches and staff, never spends on the incidental items that make everyone feel a part of a great organization, and like someone else said.... the refrigerators are locked during off hours. He worries about ther $1.25 gatorade bottle more so that hiring a competent staff that can continuelly win seasons.

This family is still cheap as all get out. Sure they may be spending for the new training facility. But, bet your bottom dollar it is to create more wealth for his family. In 10 years, that Scottsdale land will triple in value.
 

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
17,301
Reaction score
19,782
You – and many others – are right in that it doesn’t hit the other owners financially that Cardinals is a joke on the field,
Warning: what follows has a high speculation content

I think the NFL is like most businesses. It has 32 "locations" that all have financial targets.

Phoenix is a top 10 market in the US. In a league where the "locations" arent optimized to population (see Jacksonville, Green Bay, Buffalo, New Orleans, Indianapolis, etc) - having a top 10 metro perform financially like its down in the 20s or worse would be a problem.

I bet Mike is hearing about it from both sides: the family with its hands out, and the NFL league office telling him he is underperforming
 

some dumb guy

Hall of Famer
Joined
Nov 4, 2022
Posts
2,058
Reaction score
3,204
Pick'em
#9 · 135 pts
Location
Phoenix, Az
I'm not sure a couple of billboards and some very little criticism from the fans will make a difference. The Saints went through the '80s with the fans in paper bags in the stadium with "Aints" on them and nothing really happened.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
45,690
Reaction score
45,366
Location
Gilbert, AZ
I'm not sure a couple of billboards and some very little criticism from the fans will make a difference. The Saints went through the '80s with the fans in paper bags in the stadium with "Aints" on them and nothing really happened.
That was 40 years ago my dude

The billboards won’t do much but if you can make it uncomfortable to be a Bidwill in the rich people bubble he’ll start to get pressured.

No one wants to go to school and hear that Big Cat put uncle Mike and the family on blast. Thats the kind of thing that gets talked about at the dinner table.
 

Brian in Mesa

Advocatus Diaboli
Super Moderator
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
82,600
Reaction score
38,933
Pick'em
#6 · 330 pts
Location
Killjoy Central
Yes, obviously if it doesn’t happen in two weeks it’s not worth trying
It's been in the Bidwill family since 1933. It's not going anywhere. Even if Michael were pressured to sell because of a scandal (which he is not), he would simply step into the shadows, let another sibling take over the everyday operations, and the family would still own the team. This isn't rocket science, but hey, some local fan who does food reviews spent $8,100 of his own money on some billboards so it has got to work this time, right? Drop a follow !! :D
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
45,690
Reaction score
45,366
Location
Gilbert, AZ
It's been in the Bidwill family since 1933. It's not going anywhere. Even if Michael were pressured to sell because of a scandal (which he is not), he would simply step into the shadows, let another sibling take over the everyday operations, and the family would still own the team. This isn't rocket science, but hey, some local fan who does food reviews spent $8,100 of his own money on some billboards so it has got to work this time, right? Drop a follow !! :D
If it gets Michael to step away from football operations, would you consider that a win?

Fans don’t have any other levers to embarrass the current president to try something different. He just fired the coach; he’ll probably fire the GM in 10 weeks.

This effort is cringe, no doubt, but getting some national publicity around how embarrassing this franchise is not is a good thing.
 

RON_IN_OC

https://www.ronevansrealty.com
Joined
Mar 10, 2004
Posts
31,371
Reaction score
44,474
Location
Rancho Santa Margarita, CA
If it gets Michael to step away from football operations, would you consider that a win?

Fans don’t have any other levers to embarrass the current president to try something different. He just fired the coach; he’ll probably fire the GM in 10 weeks.

This effort is cringe, no doubt, but getting some national publicity around how embarrassing this franchise is not is a good thing.
Do you honestly think if Mike hired someone to take football control, they would have complete autonomy? I don't...they may at the beginning, especially for optics, but once there are a few questionable moves made and the press makes a big deal about it, Mike will step back in.
 

Cheesebeef

ASFN IDOL
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2003
Posts
99,065
Reaction score
85,958
If it gets Michael to step away from football operations, would you consider that a win?

Fans don’t have any other levers to embarrass the current president to try something different. He just fired the coach; he’ll probably fire the GM in 10 weeks.

This effort is cringe, no doubt, but getting some national publicity around how embarrassing this franchise is not is a good thing.
even Wolfley is consistently pushing the narrative for Michael to step down and replace him with a Fitz-like figure on state-radio. I don't know if all this negative attention will ultimately make a difference, but I do feel like we're at a different level of scorn and ridicule heaped upon this franchise right now, especially when it's starting to come from it's biggest homers in house-ish (I know Wolf isn't an announcer anymore) and making the rounds nationally.

wairt... you think this effort is NOT a good thing?
 

AsUpRoDiGy

Magnanimous
Joined
Apr 13, 2009
Posts
8,660
Reaction score
8,409
Pick'em
#18 · 20 pts
Location
Phx
Do you honestly think if Mike hired someone to take football control, they would have complete autonomy? I don't...they may at the beginning, especially for optics, but once there are a few questionable moves made and the press makes a big deal about it, Mike will step back in.
I think anything that gets Mikey to take a step back is a huge win. Even if he has one less finger in the cookie jar...that's a very good thing.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
45,690
Reaction score
45,366
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Do you honestly think if Mike hired someone to take football control, they would have complete autonomy? I don't...they may at the beginning, especially for optics, but once there are a few questionable moves made and the press makes a big deal about it, Mike will step back in.

I don’t know what “complete” means. The idea would be that someone credible would only come here if they’re given clear contractual authority.

Otherwise Michael will just hire another toady GM and cut his legs out from under him.

even Wolfley is consistently pushing the narrative for Michael to step down and replace him with a Fitz-like figure on state-radio. I don't know if all this negative attention will ultimately make a difference, but I do feel like we're at a different level of scorn and ridicule heaped upon this franchise right now, especially when it's starting to come from it's biggest homers in house-ish (I know Wolf isn't an announcer anymore) and making the rounds nationally.

wairt... you think this effort is NOT a good thing?

I think the effort is cringe but it’s been more effective than I expected. We’ll see if they can maintain momentum.

Wolfley is a weird case. Him and Calvisi are still doing the Big Red Rage, which I think the Cards are buying time to broadcast. Maybe there just running out a separate contract?

BRR has been around a very long time. It’s really changed form after COVID (probably); they used to make it a live show and a weekly happy hour for cards staff. It’s not that anymore. I’m not sure why it exists.
 

Crimson Warrior

Ready For The Next Chapter
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2002
Posts
10,384
Reaction score
14,104
Location
Home of the Thunder
That was 40 years ago my dude

The billboards won’t do much but if you can make it uncomfortable to be a Bidwill in the rich people bubble he’ll start to get pressured.

No one wants to go to school and hear that Big Cat put uncle Mike and the family on blast. Thats the kind of thing that gets talked about at the dinner table.

This assumes billionaires like the Bidwills have a mentality, and a perception of reality, that is similar to what you and I have kerouac9.

Unfortunately, I’m confident they do not.
 

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
17,301
Reaction score
19,782
Kinda the inherent problem is Bidwill will likely act worse as pressure mounts. Thats how his personality works. So buckle up for continued bad times. But that’ll end up forcing the leagues hand eventually
I am trying to imagine what that looks like

Like hiring John Gruden or something like that?
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
45,690
Reaction score
45,366
Location
Gilbert, AZ
This assumes billionaires like the Bidwills have a mentality, and a perception of reality, that is similar to what you and I have kerouac9.

Unfortunately, I’m confident they do not.
The family are billionaires; the individual kids are insecure AF because they are living on the ****, everyone knows it, and when the team is bad all the old stuff about Bill Sr, etc bubbles back up to the surface.

Rich teens listen to Pardon My Take; rich teens are more like normal teens than rich adults.

#bidwillout is about puncturing that bubble of privilege.
 

dreamcastrocks

Chopped Liver Moderator
Super Moderator
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2005
Posts
47,422
Reaction score
14,190
Followers is a shorthand for rando no one should care about.

If you’re going to post any tweets, ADD SOMETHING to the conversation. If you’re just dumping someone’s random thought on our doorstep, you’re like the dog who brings a dead bird into the house as a present.

I do not care what JoannaCards opinion is on anything. I’ve never seen someone here pick up a tweet someone posts and continue that line of conversation.

If people are interested in random tweets, everyone knows where to find them. It shouldn’t be on ASFN.
You aren't allowed to tell others what to post. Consider this a warning.
 

602 Native

Strawman
Joined
Nov 1, 2023
Posts
7,736
Reaction score
13,351
Location
Gilbert
Oh snap. National coverage?

Has it forced him to sell the team yet? :shrug:

You must be registered for see images
By bringing national attention to it the hope is that it brings change not necessarily for him to sell.

Same thing happened with the player grades. He ponied up for a new facility.

I know you are all in for giving your cash to the PV Nepo Baby Hillbilly without any improvements but some of us actually care about the reputation of Arizona and how the Cardinals bring it down.
 

Cardinals Pick'em

LAR @ ARI
Nov 15, 2026 at 2:05 PM
Make your pick
17 member(s) have picked so far. Picks are revealed at kickoff.
+ 12 more games to pick this week
Season leaders
🥇 Phrazbit Phrazbit 495
🥈 Devilmaycare Devilmaycare 470
🥉 Adrian Adrian 410
🥉 RedViper RedViper 410
5 Shane Shane 335

Survivor Pool

5 of 13 still standing
Week 10 · last kickoff Nov 16, 2026 at 6:15 PM

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
1,552,130
Posts
6,836,238
Members
6,456
Latest member
DesertRat
Top