I'm not ChatGPT, but let's see what I can do, just comparing a few stats. Pro-football-reference doesn't allow you to aggregate stats over multiple discrete ranges, so I got very close approximations by aggregating season-by-season or month-by-month, then calculating weighted averages based on the number of games played in each group.
Murray career pre/post Call of Duty release*:
- pre (37 games): 21-15-1 record (.581), 56 TD, 25 INT (2.24:1), 7.2 y/a, 94.5 passer rating
- post (45 games): 15-30 record (.333), 59 TD, 32 INT (1.84:1), 6.8 y/a, 90.5 passer rating
Darnold career Sep-Oct / Nov-Jan:
- early (36 games): 17-19 record (.472), 40 TD, 37 INT (1.08:1), 6.8 y/a, 78.6 passer rating
- late (47 games): 26-21 record (.553), 58 TD, 31 INT (1.87:1), 7.1 y/a, 88.4 passer rating
Tagovailoa career Sep-Oct / Nov-Jan:
- early (23 games): 14-9 record (.609), 40 TD, 18 INT (2.22:1), 8.2 y/a, 101.9 passer rating
- late (41 games): 26-15 record (.634), 60 TD, 26 INT (2.31:1), 7.3 y/a, 96.6 passer rating
Lawrence career Sep-Oct / Nov-Jan:
- early (31 games): 11-20 record (.355), 38 TD, 23 INT (1.65:1), 6.9 y/a, 86.5 passer rating
- late (29 games): 11-18 record (.379), 31 TD, 23 INT (1.35:1), 6.7 y/a, 83.6 passer rating
Comparison:
Murray's W-L percentage drops by .248 (!), while each of the other three's W-L percentage improves by .047 on average. Murray is by miles the worst of the four.
Muray's TD:INT ratio drops by 0.4, while Darnold's and Tagovailoa's improve by .485 and Lawrence's drops by 0.3. Murray is the worst of the four.
Murray's yards per attempt drops by 0.4. Darnod's increases by 0.3, Tagovailoas's drops by 0.9, and Lawrence's drops by 0.2. Murray ranks third out of the four.
Murray's passer rating drops by 4 points. Darnold's increases by 9.8, Tagovailoa's drops by 5.3, and Lawrence's drops by 2.9. Murray ranks third out of the four.
Is that what you were looking for?
* 25 Oct 2019, 13 Nov 2020, 5 Nov 2021, 10 Nov 2023, and 25 Oct 2024... so, basically similar to the Sep-Oct vs. Nov-Jan split for the others.