fordronken

Suns Trade:
Shawn Marion
Marcus Banks
#24 Pick
#29 Pick

Clippers Trade:
Corey Maggette
Sam Cassell
Aaron Williams
#14 Pick

Result for Suns:
• Suns drop 3 million dollars in salary(basically removing Marcus Banks' contract immediately).

• Suns get a back up point guard next year (with an expiring contract, which is doubly good because it puts Sam Cassell in a contract year).

• Suns get a poor man's Shawn Marion who is making less than half the money.

• Suns get an expiring contract in Aaron Williams.

• Suns move up in the draft.

Result for Clippers:
• Clippers move the guy that Dunleavy hates (Maggette).

• Clippers get a legitimate All-Star to pair with Elton Brand and one of the top small forwards in the game.

elindholm

With Cassell about to turn 38, I don't think the "contract year" bump is in play anymore. I'm concerned that his numbers nose-dived last year; he might be running on fumes at this point in his career. But he could probably be effective for 20 minutes a game, which is all the Suns would want.

Williams is pretty bad, but I guess he did okay with those open-court Nets teams right after they got Kidd. Since Marion has only two years left, I think the Suns need to keep an eye on what kind of talent they get back, instead of looking at a pure salary dump.

Maggette is terrific when he's healthy and has his head in the right place. Offensively this trade is good for the Suns, but they would take a step back defensively and it's risky because all three Clippers players have injury histories.

I definitely don't think the Suns should have to include their own pick. Ten spots isn't a big move in this draft (from what I gather), so the Clippers should be willing to swap #14 for #24 based on the other incentives you laid out.

__________________

signature pending

where's elindholm, i need to vomit again! -- Ouchie-Z-Clown

AsUdUdE

no matter how "good" the trade would seem, you don't trade a perennial All-Star within the division to a team in desperate need of someone like him, unless it is for a perennial all star in return...

That trade wouldn't work unless it was marion for Brand.....

JS22

Ignoring financials, (I know, you can't) the only trade I'd do involving Marion / Magette is:

Marion
#24

For:

Magette
Cassell
#14

Magette is trash to the Clippers and Casell is as as over the hill as they come. Though he would be great for 10-15 minutes.

__________________
Before you criticize someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticize them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

fordronken

You don't want to dump Banks?

slinslin

I dont think we should give up a pick in this scenario. Think Marion is worth Magette #14 and fillers.

__________________
Tier 1 Noel and McLemore
Tier 2 Oladipo, Porter, Shabazz and Burke
Tier 3 McCollum, Caldwell-Powell, Gobert, Schroeder

arwillan

i dont like the idea. losing marion makes us lose a rebounder and defender, the suns 2 biggest weaknesses.

__________________

azirish

We don't have a lot of Clipper fans on this board, but it has never seemed like the LA based Suns fans were nearly as interested in the team getting Maggette as people living in other ares. Dunleavy is not the first Clipper coach to have problems with him.

My read on it is that Maggette is far more effective against the Suns than the rest of the NBA.

dodie53

i like maggette because he doesn't settle for jumpshots..
and i think he can defend and rebound a little..

__________________
“You can’t worry about things you have no control over.”

"Above and Beyond"

-- Steve Nash

"I don't even care how much I score.
I just want to win."
-- Ron Artest

cly2tw

Donald Sterling is not gonna pay 16 mil for Marion. Period. If I were Clipps, I'd rather do Artest for Maggette.

azirish

I think the Suns have a real need for someone who can drive the basket and is physically strong enough to finish. However, I'd rather look for that in the draft than to give up Marion for a backup.

slinslin

Geez Gambo is so clueless I mean he seriously said right now that Magette is the worst defensive player in the NBA.

__________________
Tier 1 Noel and McLemore
Tier 2 Oladipo, Porter, Shabazz and Burke
Tier 3 McCollum, Caldwell-Powell, Gobert, Schroeder

azirish

That's hard to believe. There are some amazingly bad defenders out there.

masterphomeg

I'd have to say no.

__________________
"I don't know, Bob...what do you think?"